The High Court, Criminal Division, in Ghana has dismissed a bail application by Bernard Antwi Boasiako, the former Ashanti Regional Chairman of the New Patriotic Party (NPP), popularly known as Chairman Wontumi. Wontumi, who is currently serving a prison sentence at the Nsawam Medium Security Prison, had filed a motion for bail pending appeal on August 5. His counsel, Samuel Atta Akyea, argued that the appeal raised substantial legal and constitutional questions.
According to counsel, the appeal challenges the trial court’s failure to consider relevant provisions of the mining legislation and raises constitutional questions that needed to be addressed. The applicant's counsel also maintained that Wontumi's presence was necessary to enable him to give proper instructions to his legal team in prosecuting the appeal. Furthermore, counsel argued that the applicant was not a flight risk, citing that his passport was in the custody of the Economic and Organised Crime Office (EOCO).
However, the Deputy Attorney-General, Dr Justice Srem-Sai, opposed the application, arguing that the appeal had no genuine likelihood of success. He submitted that Wontumi’s presence was not necessary for his lawyers to prosecute the appeal, particularly as the arguments could be adequately presented through written submissions. The prosecution further argued that the grounds of appeal did not disclose exceptional circumstances to justify granting bail.
In its ruling, the court acknowledged the detailed nature of the applicant’s appeal but stressed that the fact that an appeal had been extensively presented did not automatically make it arguable or likely to succeed. Justice Audrey Kocuvie-Tay, who presided over the court, observed that counsel had not identified any specific provision of the legislation that supported the applicant’s argument during the trial.
The court consequently found no arguable basis in the contention that the trial judge had failed to properly interpret the mining legislation. The judge also rejected the applicant’s argument concerning the alleged failure to consider the conduct of the third accused person. She held that Wontumi had been convicted on the basis of his own conduct and found the ground of appeal unarguable.
The court further considered the evidence of prosecution witness PW2 and the applicant’s arguments concerning the interpretation of the relevant legal provisions. After examining the materials before it, Justice Kocuvie-Tay concluded that the appeal was neither arguable nor demonstrated a likelihood of success. As a result, she dismissed the application for bail pending appeal.
The dismissal means that Wontumi will remain in custody at the Nsawam Medium Security Prison. The court's decision was based on a thorough examination of the applicant's arguments and the evidence presented. Wontumi's conviction and subsequent bail application have garnered significant attention in Ghana's legal and political circles.
Key points
- The High Court dismissed Wontumi's bail application due to lack of arguable basis in his appeal.
- Wontumi's counsel argued that his client's presence was necessary for the appeal, but the prosecution disagreed.
- The court's decision was based on a thorough examination of the applicant's arguments and evidence.
Reporting sources
- Wontumi’s plea for bail pending appeal fails · The Ghanaian Chronicle