A professional rugby player from South Africa has lost a court case over his brother's luxury Jaguar. Mzwanele Richman Zito claimed the R750,000 vehicle was a gift from his brother, Andile Wiseman Zitho. However, the Free State high court found his evidence inconsistent and unreliable. The court ruled that Mzwanele must return the Jaguar XF to his brother and sign documents to transfer its registration.

The dispute between the brothers began in 2023 when they changed the vehicle's registration from Andile's name to Mzwanele's. Andile claimed this was done to avoid traffic fines incurred by Mzwanele being issued in his name. However, Mzwanele argued that his brother had given him the Jaguar because he loved the vehicle. The court heard that both brothers understood the car belonged to Andile and Mzwanele was just allowed to drive it.

The court found that Mzwanele's claim of being given the Jaguar as a gift was an "afterthought and a recent fabrication". Acting judge R Sepato questioned why Mzwanele only told his lawyer about the alleged gift on the evening before he testified. The judge also noted that Mzwanele's account changed during his testimony, including over which vehicle his earlier court pleadings referred to.

The judge accepted Andile's evidence that he had bought the Jaguar and retained the original registration certificate and spare keys. The court found that the registration certificate in Mzwanele's name did not prove ownership. Registration under the National Road Traffic Act was not conclusive proof of ownership under common law. Andile is a regional manager at an undisclosed institution.

Mzwanele and Andile had a close relationship and lived together in Andile's Bloemfontein home for several years. Andile often let Mzwanele use his vehicles without charging him, including a Polo, two Audis, a Volkswagen Amarok, and the Jaguar. Andile also helped Mzwanele acquire vehicles by buying them in his own name due to Mzwanele's poor credit record.

The judgment ordered Mzwanele to pay the legal costs of the case, including counsel's fees. Mzwanele had played for the Griquas and later the Cheetahs. The court ruled that he must immediately return the car, valued at over R750,000, and sign documents to transfer its registration back into his brother's name.

The dispute arose from a failed joint property investment between the brothers, but the court rejected Mzwanele's suggestion that the demand for the Jaguar was an act of revenge. The court found Mzwanele's version of events "totally improbable" and ruled in favor of Andile. The brothers had made the Jaguar available for Mzwanele's use in 2021, with the understanding that it belonged to Andile.

Key points

  • The court ruled that Mzwanele's claim of being given the Jaguar as a gift was an "afterthought and a recent fabrication".
  • Mzwanele must return the R750,000 Jaguar to his brother and sign documents to transfer its registration.
  • The dispute between the brothers began over a failed joint property investment and the use of the Jaguar.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.