A national effort to ensure the president is elected by popular vote is gaining momentum after significant Democratic wins in the midterm elections. The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, an agreement among states to award their presidential electoral votes to the winner of the nationwide popular vote, could soon surpass the 270 electoral votes required to go into effect. Currently, 18 Democratic-led states and the District of Columbia have joined the compact, totaling 222 electoral votes.

Five states that will soon have Democratic control – Arizona, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Nevada, and Wisconsin – add up to 61 electoral votes. Combinations of at least four of these states would put the compact over the 270-vote threshold. Governors and incoming governors in Pennsylvania and Nevada have expressed openness to signing legislation that would bring their states into the interstate agreement. However, other governors have yet to publicly weigh in on the issue.

One of the major questions surrounding this effort is whether states, particularly presidential battlegrounds, would be willing to give up their significant influence in elections ahead of the 2028 presidential contests. Leaders in each state will have to consider whether they want to be the tipping point in moving forward a movement that could change how the US decides presidential winners. Some Democrats, such as Arizona Gov. Katie Hobbs, have previously supported the measure but have not recently commented on whether her state should sign on.

The compact faces several legal and logistical hurdles. Some legal scholars argue that the agreement between states could violate the compact clause in the Constitution, which requires congressional consent for interstate agreements. Norman Miller, a constitutional law professor at Willamette University, also sees practical issues with the compact, including the potential for tension between states with different voting rules and the risk of upending the decentralized nature of American presidential elections.

Proponents of the compact, however, argue that it would not require significant changes to the current system. John Koza, chairman of National Popular Vote, says that current state and federal law provide for the issuance of a certified vote count from each state, which can simply be added up. He believes that the compact would force presidential candidates to appeal to a broader range of voters and make all voters feel like their vote matters.

Critics of the National Popular Vote, such as Save Our States, argue that abolishing the Electoral College would lead to more regional politics and exacerbate existing divides. Some argue that a constitutional amendment would be a more suitable way to address the issue, as it would provide a more comprehensive solution to the challenges of conducting a national popular vote for the presidency. A similar effort to pass an amendment to abolish the Electoral College in 1969 ultimately failed.

Despite the challenges, Patrick Rosenstiel, a senior consultant to National Popular Vote, remains optimistic about the compact's prospects. He believes that 63% of American voters can get what they want – a national popular vote for president – in the 2028 presidential election. Rosenstiel argues that the compact would solve multiple problems at once, including making all voters feel valued and forcing presidential candidates to appeal to a broader range of voters.

Key points

  • The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact could soon surpass 270 electoral votes needed to bypass the Electoral College.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.