The Libyan Supreme Court's Administrative Appeals Chamber has ruled on an appeal lodged by the Social Security Fund's head and the director of its Misrata branch against a retired military officer, Fawzi Hassani Al-Yamani. The court accepted the appeal in form but rejected it in substance. This ruling upholds a previous decision by the Tripoli Court of Appeals to increase Al-Yamani's pension benefits and pay him arrears based on a 2013 cabinet decision.

The dispute originated from a lawsuit filed by Al-Yamani against the Social Security Fund. The Tripoli Court of Appeals had ruled in his favor, annulling a 2019 decision by the Social Security Disputes Committee and ordering the payment of increased pension benefits as per a 2013 cabinet resolution. The Supreme Court found that the appeal lodged by the Social Security Fund's management did not provide sufficient grounds for overturning the lower court's decision.

The Supreme Court's decision is based on the principle that changes to legislation, such as the 2013 and 2018 resolutions regarding Libyan military personnel salaries, have immediate and direct effects on existing legal situations. The court argued that this does not constitute a retroactive application of the law, provided that its implementation is limited to the period from the date it took effect.

The court's ruling also highlighted that denying the pension increase would contravene the principle of equality among individuals in similar legal situations. Furthermore, the court noted that a 2015 budget law exempted increases for armed forces personnel from payment, making it unjustifiable to rely on a 2014 budget law provision to deny Al-Yamani the benefit.

The issue of pension disparities and delayed payments is a significant concern for over half a million Libyan retirees, who face difficult living conditions. Many retirees receive pensions as low as 900 Libyan dinars per month, which is insufficient to cover basic living expenses given the rising cost of goods and services.

Libyan retirees frequently organize protests to demand the payment of legally mandated increases in their pensions and to press for transparency regarding which groups are eligible for these benefits. They also call for the settlement of debts owed to the Social Security Fund, which have impacted its ability to meet its obligations.

The Supreme Court's decision is expected to have implications for the Social Security Fund and the Libyan government's handling of military pensions. The ruling underscores the need for the government to address the systemic issues affecting retirees, including the timely payment of pensions and adjustments to benefits in line with economic conditions.

Key points

  • The Libyan Supreme Court has rejected an appeal by the Social Security Fund against a ruling granting increased pension benefits and back payments to a retired military officer.
  • The decision upholds a lower court ruling and is based on the principle of equality among individuals in similar legal situations.
  • The case highlights the challenges faced by Libyan retirees, including low pension benefits and delayed payments.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.