Claudy Siar Criticizes Racism Behind 'Issus de l'Immigration' Expression

Claudy Siar, a special envoy to Benin's President Romuald Wadagni, has spoken out against what he describes as racism behind the French expression "issus de l'immigration" (from immigration). In a video posted on social media on November 7, Siar expressed his personal views, stating that this phrase is "probably the most racist of the moment." He argues that it allows people to say things about black or Arab French citizens that they would never say about white French citizens.

Siar, who has been fighting for human dignity for over thirty years, says he is sometimes frustrated not being in the midst of the controversy. He has a history of denouncing racism, including in March 2026 when he spoke out against "undercover racism." In 2024, he defended Aya Nakamura against racist comments before the Paris Olympics and reported photos of French police suspected of racism to the authorities. Siar emphasizes that his fight for equality will not be silenced, even if it means losing his contracts.

According to Siar, the "colonial and slavery mindset" remains ingrained in French society. He attributes this to a flawed education system that has failed to make all students feel fully French. Siar points to the violent history of colonization, land expropriation, and the extermination of indigenous peoples. He advocates for a more nuanced history that highlights humanity's kindness and empathy. Siar also criticizes the law on racist separatism and argues that delinquency is a social issue, not one of origin.

Siar questions how former Prime Minister Édouard Philippe can use such language, implying that it perpetuates racism. He recalls being applauded by over 3,000 people at the 2021 Africa-France summit in Montpellier. Siar emphasizes that his views are not those of extremist groups and that his goal is to promote a France that respects all its citizens. He expresses solidarity with those fighting for equality and against racism.

The expression "issus de l'immigration" has sparked controversy in France, with many arguing that it stigmatizes people of immigrant backgrounds. Siar's comments have sparked a national conversation about racism and identity in France. His statements have been met with both support and criticism, highlighting the complexities of discussing these issues in France.

Siar's fight against racism is not limited to his comments on the expression "issus de l'immigration." He has been actively working to promote equality and challenge racist attitudes in French society. His efforts have been recognized by many, who see him as a champion of human rights and dignity. Siar's message is clear: he will continue to speak out against racism, even in the face of adversity.

As France continues to grapple with issues of identity and racism, Siar's comments serve as a reminder of the need for ongoing dialogue and reflection. His advocacy for a more inclusive and equitable society is a crucial part of this conversation. The impact of his words will likely be felt for some time, as France continues to navigate its complex history and ongoing social issues.

Key points

• Claudy Siar argues that the expression "issus de l'immigration" is racist because it allows people to say things about black or Arab French citizens that they would never say about white French citizens.