The City of Cape Town is resisting a request for information from Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs (Cogta) Minister Velenkosini Hlabisa regarding the proposed disposal of approximately 5.6 hectares of municipal land in Strandfontein to Christel House South Africa. This land sale is intended for educational and social-care purposes. The City published a notice of the proposed disposal, which has received public support from the Western Cape Education Department, Wesgro, and the Edu Invest initiative.
ANC MP Nombiselo Sompa-Masiu had asked Hlabisa whether Cogta's mandate included overseeing the disposal of land by municipalities. In response, Hlabisa stated that the disposal of municipal capital assets is governed by the Municipal Finance Management Act (MFMA). He emphasized that a municipality may not permanently dispose of a capital asset needed to provide basic municipal services. The MFMA requires the municipal council to consider the asset's fair market value and the economic and community value to be received in exchange.
Hlabisa noted that he does not approve individual municipal property-disposal transactions, but national and provincial governments exercise their constitutional and statutory support, monitoring, and oversight responsibilities in relation to local government. The City of Cape Town, not Cogta, is responsible for determining whether the property may be disposed of and on what terms. Hlabisa's response was based on information available to him, but the City of Cape Town declined to provide additional information.
The City Manager declined to provide a response to Hlabisa's request, contending that the question did not comply with Rule 134(5)(b) of the Rules of the National Assembly. The City's spokesperson, Luthando Tyhalibongo, stated that a parliamentary question can only be asked to a minister about information held by him or his department. He argued that the City is accountable to its councillors, not MPs, and that the parliamentary question fell outside the rules and practice.
The proposed land sale has undergone a public participation process, which has been concluded. The comments, objections, and alternative proposals received during this process have been assessed and considered. The matter is currently undergoing legal review as part of the City's internal due process. Once completed, the matter will be considered by the relevant decision-making authorities to determine the outcome of the proposal.
The City had previously described the proposed sale as an opportunity to put a significant municipal asset to productive use while supporting greater access to quality education for children and young people in an underserved community. This development is being closely watched, as the South African Human Rights Commission has lodged an application in the Western Cape High Court to interdict the City of Cape Town in the transfer of 49 municipal properties, pending a review application.
The dispute over the proposed land sale and the City's refusal to provide information have raised concerns about transparency and accountability in municipal decision-making. Cogta will, through the local government MEC Anton Bredell, request that the City reconsider its position and furnish the information held in its records that is necessary to respond to the question. The outcome of the proposed land sale and the ongoing dispute remain to be seen.
Key points
- The City of Cape Town has refused to provide details on the proposed Christel House land sale, citing its municipal function.
- The proposed land sale is intended for educational and social-care purposes to support greater access to quality education for children and young people in an underserved community.
- The dispute over the proposed land sale has raised concerns about transparency and accountability in municipal decision-making.