The Constitutional Court of Zimbabwe has heard the first of five challenges against Constitutional Amendment No. 3 (CAA 3), with seven judges reserving their decision. The case was brought by Vrante Mahlupeko of the National Constitutional Assembly (NCA), represented by Professor Lovemore Madhuku. Mahlupeko argues that Parliament introduced ten new constitutional provisions without public scrutiny, contrary to section 328(3)–(4) of the Constitution.
The Government argued that Parliament could amend a Constitutional Bill without restarting the 90-day publication and consultation process. However, Madhuku challenged this defence, stating that the dispute was not about Parliament's power to amend a Bill, but its authority to introduce entirely new constitutional provisions never published for public scrutiny. Section 328(3) requires the precise terms of a Constitutional Bill to be published at least 90 days before its introduction in Parliament.
Madhuku warned of the consequences of allowing Parliament to introduce new provisions without public consultation, stating that it could lead to the Constitution being fundamentally rewritten without the people's knowledge or consent. The Government turned to an earlier Constitutional Court judgment in Mushoriwa and Others v Parliament of Zimbabwe and Another, CCZ 04/23, which held that Parliament could introduce substantive amendments without automatically restarting the 90-day publication period.
Madhuku challenged this interpretation, arguing that the power to amend a published Bill cannot become an unlimited licence to introduce entirely new constitutional provisions never presented to the people. He also argued that delegated power cannot override sovereign power, and that Parliament cannot invoke authority entrusted to it by the people to circumvent the constitutional protections of their sovereignty.
The arguments then turned to presidential tenure, with the Government arguing that section 95 had been overridden, not amended. Madhuku disagreed, citing Mupungu v Minister of Justice, CCZ 07/21 (2021), which concerned extending judges' retirement age from 70 to 75. The Court expressly identified the President's five-year term under section 95(2) as a constitutional term limit.
The most consequential argument concerned the fate of CAA 3, with Madhuku arguing that the entire Act must fall because the constitutional violation affected the legislative process itself. Section 117(2) requires Parliament to amend the Constitution in accordance with section 328, and Parliamentary approval cannot cure a constitutionally defective process.
The judges, comprising Justices Elizabeth Gwaunza, George Chiweshe, Ben Hlatshwayo, Bharat Patel, Rita Makarau, Susan Mavangira, and Antonia Guvava, have reserved their decision. The outcome of this case has significant implications for Zimbabwe's constitutional destiny, with the people awaiting the judges' decision and the bigger politics that will follow.
Key points
- The Constitutional Court of Zimbabwe has heard a challenge to Amendment No. 3, with Professor Lovemore Madhuku arguing that Parliament introduced ten new constitutional provisions without public consultation.
- Madhuku argued that the entire Act must fall because the constitutional violation affected the legislative process itself.
- The outcome of this case has significant implications for Zimbabwe's constitutional destiny.