Zimbabwean advocate and former student leader Tinomudaishe Chinyoka has expressed skepticism over the Harare City Council's recent decision to temporarily suspend home demolitions. In his opinion piece, Chinyoka argues that the council's move deserves no praise as it only offers temporary relief to residents. He believes that the demolitions are unlawful and have been ongoing since at least 2013, despite a clear constitutional provision protecting residents' rights.
Chinyoka points to Section 74 of the Constitution of Zimbabwe, which states that no person may be evicted from their home or have their home demolished without a court order that considers all relevant circumstances. He argues that the council has treated this provision as a mere suggestion, instead relying on administrative notices and dubious court orders to justify the demolitions. This has resulted in numerous families being left without representation or recourse.
The advocate criticizes the council's use of the Regional, Town and Country Planning Act to issue 48-hour administrative "enforcement orders" or "prohibition orders" as a substitute for judicial eviction orders. He notes that even when the High Court or Constitutional Court has ruled that such administrative notices are insufficient, municipal lawyers continue to use them to justify demolitions.
Chinyoka also highlights the council's tactic of suing only a single cooperative, defunct trust, or land baron as the respondent, leaving hundreds of bona fide homeowners unrepresented and unaware that their homes are at risk. He argues that this approach prevents judicial officers from considering all relevant circumstances, as mandated by the Constitution.
Furthermore, Chinyoka accuses the council of recycling stale, generic orders to justify demolitions. He claims that council lawyers obtain interdicts barring construction on vacant land, only to dust them off years later to justify flattening established suburbs. Chinyoka argues that such orders are not warrants to demolish occupied homes.
Chinyoka believes that the true motivations behind the demolitions are often rooted in politics, with settlements being tolerated or targeted based on the patronage of land barons. He argues that the council's actions are often driven by a desire to punish certain individuals or groups, rather than a genuine concern for town planning standards or environmental protection.
Ultimately, Chinyoka's criticism of the Harare City Council's temporary moratorium on home demolitions centers on its failure to address the underlying issues of unlawful evictions and inadequate protection for residents' rights. He argues that a more comprehensive approach is needed to ensure that residents are safeguarded against arbitrary demolitions and that their rights are respected.
Key points
- The Harare City Council's temporary moratorium on home demolitions has been criticized for not providing permanent legal protection to residents.
Reporting sources
- Chinyoka on Tuesday: All hail a moratorium on the unlawful? · Nehanda Radio