The US Senate is scrutinizing Liberia's deportation deal with the US, which allows for up to 1,200 people to be deported to Liberia. The deal, described by the Liberian government as an act of hospitality, has raised concerns among US lawmakers. Senator Tim Kaine, a Virginia Democrat on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, filed Senate Resolution 886, which demands that the US Secretary of State provide Congress with information on Liberia's human rights practices within 30 days.

The resolution, referred to the Foreign Relations Committee, seeks to uncover information on alleged human rights abuses in Liberia, including arbitrary arrest and detention, torture, and human trafficking. It specifically asks about the treatment of non-citizens removed to Liberia by the US and whether US security assistance could end up supporting abusive practices. The resolution also requests information on conditions in detention centers, agreements and financial transactions between the two governments, and meetings between Liberian and US officials.

The resolution is backed by Section 502B(c) of the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961, which allows Congress to demand a human rights report on any country. If the State Department misses the 30-day deadline, US security assistance to Liberia will be frozen until the report is delivered. The resolution is privileged, enabling its sponsor to force a floor vote if Senate leaders prefer to avoid one. Liberia's deal with the US stands out as one of the largest of its kind, with at least 35 countries signing similar agreements.

The Liberian government has claimed that it neither demanded nor received any compensation for accepting deportees. However, the US awarded Liberia $5 million for "migration management," and The New York Times reported that $7.5 million was wired to the country. Liberian officials have stated that accommodation, food, and onward travel for deportees will be paid for by Washington and an international partner organization.

The deportation deal has sparked controversy in Liberia, with critics arguing that it is unconstitutional. Article 34(f) of Liberia's Constitution gives the Legislature the power to approve treaties and "other international agreements." Nimba County Senator Samuel Kogar and Liberian scholar Robtel Neajai Pailey have questioned whether the arrangement was brought before both Houses of the Legislature.

The US has described Liberia as "a thriving democracy" with strong human rights protections. However, Washington's annual human rights reports on Liberia have documented harsh prison conditions, lengthy pre-trial detention, and weak courts. The resolution will test these claims against the State Department's own evidence, which could have implications for both governments.

While it is unlikely that the resolution will pass soon, it has brought attention to the deportation deal and set out what Congress wants to know. Previous attempts to force similar resolutions through have failed on largely party-line votes, with Republicans dismissing them as political theatre. Nevertheless, the resolutions could matter if the balance of power in Washington changes.

Key points

  • The US Senate is reviewing Liberia's human rights practices amid a deportation deal that allows for up to 1,200 people to be deported to Liberia.
  • The deal has raised concerns among US lawmakers, who are seeking information on alleged human rights abuses in Liberia.
  • The resolution could have implications for US-Liberia relations and the treatment of deportees in Liberia.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.