A federal judge has extended her block on construction of President Trump's proposed 250-foot arch in Washington D.C. for two weeks. D.C. District Judge Tanya Chutkan originally stepped in to block construction on November 5, after the National Capital Planning Commission and National Park Service gave the arch final approval. The temporary restraining order prevents the administration from initiating construction-related activities at Memorial Circle through December 3.

The lawsuit challenging the arch, initially filed by a group of Vietnam War veterans and an architectural historian, has expanded to include the governments of D.C. and Virginia, as well as nine members of the Kennedy family. They argue that the structure will block historic sightlines and cast shadows over the graves of John F. Kennedy and others at nearby Arlington National Cemetery. The plaintiffs claim the arch violates several laws, including the Commemorative Works Act and D.C.'s Height of Buildings Act.

The Trump administration has not sought congressional approval for the arch, arguing that it is covered by a 1925 authorization for a pair of 166-foot columns at the same location. The administration characterizes building the arch as a matter of urgency, citing a century-old vision and national security concerns. Trump said in September that the arch would double as a military complex, but the plans approved this month do not include details on that claim.

Another D.C. district judge, Ana Reyes, has temporarily halted the closure of the East Potomac golf course, which Trump plans to redevelop into a championship-level venue. The judge ordered the administration to keep the park open for two weeks, despite the Trump administration's announcement that it would close on November 15. The golf course is currently unstaffed, as its operator lease expired on Sunday.

The Trump administration has appealed Reyes' restraining order and proposed a schedule that would enable her to issue a final ruling by November 28. The Interior Department presented its plan for the golf course to the Commission of Fine Arts, which received over 700 public comments, almost all in opposition to the proposal. Concerns centered on reduced accessibility for golfers, cyclists, and runners, as well as the impact on historic cherry trees and major road races.

The Commission of Fine Arts Secretary Thomas Luebke noted that the public comments highlighted significant concerns about the project's impact on the community. The plaintiffs in the golf course case have asked Reyes to extend her order by two weeks, until December 12, while she considers the underlying legal issues. The administration will continue to make the case for both projects, confident that they will be vindicated as the litigation proceeds.

The fate of Trump's construction projects, including the arch and golf course, will ultimately be decided by the courts. Democrats have vowed to use their forthcoming majority in Congress to push back on Trump's construction agenda, including by blocking federal funding. The administration's plans for the arch and golf course are part of a broader effort to pursue construction projects vigorously, despite opposition from various groups and lawmakers.

Key points

  • A federal judge has extended a temporary restraining order blocking construction of President Trump's proposed arch in Washington D.C.
  • Another judge has halted the closure of the East Potomac golf course, which Trump plans to redevelop into a championship-level venue.
  • The Trump administration will continue to make the case for both projects, confident that they will be vindicated as the litigation proceeds.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.