The Malawi Communications Regulatory Authority (Macra) has suffered a setback in its $8.6 million arbitration case against software firm Precisely. A United States court has dismissed Macra's petition to enforce the arbitration award, citing failure to properly notify Precisely about the proceedings. The US District Court for New Jersey made the ruling on October 21, 2026.
According to the court's ruling, Macra failed to provide notice that would allow Precisely to participate in the proceedings and present its objections. Presiding Judge Georgette Castner found that Macra's notification method breached Precisely's due process rights. The judge noted that some courts require the respondent to demonstrate prejudice caused by deficient notice, which Precisely successfully showed.
The dispute between Macra and Precisely dates back to June 2010, when Macra signed a Master Services Agreement with Agilis, which later merged into Precisely. The agreement was for the development of a system to regulate Malawi's telecommunications industry and protect consumers. However, technical problems arose, leading to amended agreements in 2015 and 2018.
Macra initiated arbitration in 2022, and in November 2023, an arbitrator awarded the regulator $8,577,057.30 in damages and interest, along with $26,495.31 in arbitration costs. Precisely challenged the enforcement of the award, citing improper notification. Macra had sent notices to a former employee and addresses that differed from Precisely's contractually designated address in Rockville, Maryland.
The court's decision was based on the fact that the agreements required notices to be delivered personally, by international courier, or through registered or certified mail to a specified address. Email was not an agreed method of formal notice. Macra's attempts to notify Precisely were deemed insufficient, as couriers could not locate the company at the provided addresses, and telephone calls were unsuccessful.
Macra's spokesperson, Clara Mwafulirwa, was yet to respond to a questionnaire sent on Friday morning. The regulator had first entered into the Master Services Agreement on May 21, 2010, with the American firm for the supply of the Cirms. However, implementation encountered challenges when telecommunication operators in the country commenced a legal suit against implementing the Cirms.
The dismissal of Macra's petition is a significant setback for the regulator. Key points from the case include Macra's failure to properly notify Precisely, the importance of adhering to agreed notification methods, and the potential impact on Malawi's telecommunications industry.
Key points
- US court dismisses Macra's petition due to failure to properly notify Precisely.
- Macra's notification method breached Precisely's due process rights.
- The case has significant implications for Malawi's telecommunications industry.
Reporting sources
- US court dismisses Macra’spetition in K14.9bn case · The Nation