The proposed redevelopment of Kampala's Constitution Square, a historic green space, has been halted by Uganda's Cabinet, following a presidential letter directing the evaluation of a private hotel and mall project, public uproar, and conflicting legal signals. As a constitutional lawyer, Barrister Peter Magomu Mashate, notes, the sequence of events offers a revealing case study into the health of constitutionalism, the separation of powers, and the rule of law under Uganda's 1995 Constitution. The Constitution Square is a protected national monument, named in honor of the promulgation of the 1995 Constitution.

The episode exposes the persistent friction between informal "directive governance" and formal constitutionalism in Uganda. Under Article 99 of the 1995 Constitution, executive authority is vested in the President, who is required to exercise that power in accordance with the Constitution and the laws of Uganda. However, in Uganda's political culture, a presidential letter carries immense political weight, often short-circuiting statutory procedures and intimidating technical officers. This creates a presumption of approval before urban planners, environmentalists, or procurement bodies have even spoken.

The proposed redevelopment of Constitution Square reached the threshold of public alarm before being stopped, showing how vulnerable Uganda's administrative gatekeeping remains to top-down momentum. When private developers bypass the Kampala Capital City Authority (KCCA) and the Uganda Land Commission to seek direct executive blessing, they invert the legal order. The fact that this proposal was stopped shows that Cabinet deliberation, municipal pushback, and citizen vigilance can still check executive overreach.

Cabinet's decision to step back from the proposal offers a rare glimpse into the mechanics of collective executive responsibility and institutional checks. Under Article 111 of the Constitution, Cabinet is mandated to determine, formulate, and implement government policy. By sitting down, weighing the legal, historical, and political realities, and resolving to preserve the square, Cabinet demonstrated that presidential directives are neither infallible nor absolute.

The broader ecosystem of separation of powers forced this introspection, with municipal leaders at KCCA, urban planning professionals, parliamentary oversight committees examining historical leases on the land, and an outspoken citizenry exerting institutional pressure. The visible contradiction within the executive, where senior legal voices initially defended the right to redevelop the land only for Cabinet to reverse course days later, underscores that statutory reality eventually outweighs political expediency.

The rule of law prevailed in this case, with Cabinet's retreat affirming that written constitutional and statutory protections still carry enforceable weight. However, Barrister Mashate notes that Uganda's constitutional order should not require nationwide public outrage and a dramatic Cabinet U-turn to protect a gazetted national monument from unlawful alienation. A mature constitutional order should ensure that such proposals are rejected quietly and routinely at the lowest administrative desk.

The lesson of Constitution Square is twofold: Uganda's 1995 Constitution retains vital institutional pulse, but the rule of law remains overly dependent on political vigilance rather than automatic institutional enforcement. Until statutory agencies are insulated from the gravitational pull of executive letters, every public park, forest reserve, and historic square will remain only one directive away from its next existential test.

Key points

  • The proposed redevelopment of Constitution Square was halted due to public outcry and conflicting legal signals.
  • The episode highlights the friction between informal "directive governance" and formal constitutionalism in Uganda.
  • The rule of law prevailed, but Uganda's constitutional order needs to ensure that protected national monuments are safeguarded without requiring nationwide public outrage.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.