The Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) has dismissed a Nigerian man's attempt to revive his R5.4 million damages claim against the Minister of Police. Sunday Ikechukwu Okoro was arrested on July 3, 2002, after police discovered a man's body hanging in a room he had rented in Durban. Okoro claimed his arrest and detention were unlawful, resulting in loss and suffering.
Okoro was arrested without a warrant after police found the body of a man hanging by a bedsheet in the shower of room 7 at Evaleigh Court. He had rented the room two days prior to the incident. The KwaZulu-Natal High Court in Durban previously dismissed his claim, finding the police had reasonable grounds to suspect him of murder and that his arrest and detention were lawful.
A three-judge panel of the SCA comprising Acting Judge of Appeal Mjali, Acting Judge of Appeal Molitsoane, and Judge of Appeal Nicholls heard Okoro's application for reconsideration of the refusal. The majority, comprising Molitsoane and Nicholls, dismissed his application with costs. Mjali dissented, finding the police failed to establish reasonable grounds connecting Okoro to the murder.
The court heard that Warrant Officer Allen Mark Naidu and Warrant Officer Sunil Seosunker encountered Okoro outside Evaleigh Court during crime-prevention duties. Okoro led the officers to the body and appeared shocked. Naidu became suspicious that the hanging had been staged to conceal a murder due to the position of the deceased's feet and the knot around his neck.
The majority found that the circumstances surrounding the discovery of the body, Okoro's connection to the room, and the arresting officer's observations provided reasonable grounds for suspicion. The court rejected the argument that police should have obtained expert and forensic evidence before arresting Okoro, stating the legal threshold for an arrest based on reasonable suspicion was lower than the standard required to secure a criminal conviction.
The court also considered whether the Minister of Police could be held liable for Okoro's continued detention after his first court appearance on July 8, 2002. The prosecution had information from police officers, a security guard, and two post-mortem examinations. The majority found no evidence that police misled the prosecution or deliberately withheld information to ensure Okoro remained behind bars.
The SCA criticised the 18-year delay in finalising the matter, describing it as inordinate and unacceptable. The incident occurred in July 2002, while the summons was reportedly issued around October 2003, and the trial only commenced on October 19, 2020. The SCA's final order was that the application for reconsideration be struck off the roll with costs.
Key points
- The Supreme Court of Appeal dismissed a Nigerian man's R5.4 million damages claim against the Minister of Police following his arrest for murder in Durban.
- The court found that the police had reasonable grounds to suspect the man of murder and that his arrest and detention were lawful.
- The SCA criticised the 18-year delay in finalising the matter, describing it as inordinate and unacceptable.