Kenyan President William Ruto has responded to criticism from opposition leaders regarding a World Bank report on the cost of the Standard Gauge Railway (SGR) project. The report estimates that Kenya overpaid by as much as KSh117 billion for the Mombasa–Naivasha SGR. Ruto spoke at a church service in Narok on Sunday, November 15, accusing the opposition of selectively interpreting the report to advance its campaign against him.

The World Bank's 34th Kenya Economic Update, released earlier this month, covered several issues, including the SGR project's costs. The report links the project's higher costs to fraud in land compensation and a lack of competition in the contracting process. It estimates that the railway cost US$7.6 million per kilometre, compared with US$5.7 million for Tanzania's electrified railway and US$5.3 million for the Djibouti–Addis Ababa line.

Ruto argued that his administration had insisted that the World Bank make the report public, typically such reports are provided exclusively to the government and kept confidential. He accused his critics of cherry-picking from the 52-page report, which also recognizes gains made under his administration, including savings through the eCitizen digital platform and improvements to government procurement.

The opposition leaders, including Wiper Party leader Kalonzo Musyoka and Edwin Sifuna, had cited the World Bank report as evidence of corruption under Ruto's government. They made their comments at the burial of the sister of DCP leader Rigathi Gachagua in Nyeri on Saturday, November 14. Ruto has since accused his predecessor, Uhuru Kenyatta, of backing the opposition against him.

The SGR project from Mombasa to Nairobi was initiated during Kenyatta's administration and completed in 2017 at a cost of KSh327 billion, or about US$2.5 billion. The Nairobi–Naivasha section later cost KSh150 billion, or about US$1.2 billion. Construction stalled in September 2018 after China declined to provide further loans, leaving the line to terminate at Suswa in Narok County.

Ruto has since revived plans to extend the railway, breaking ground in Narok in March this year on a proposed route through Bomet and Kisumu to Malaba, estimated to cost KSh502.9 billion, or about US$3.9 billion. The opposition has rejected Ruto's claims that Kenyatta is sponsoring it, with Kalonzo urging the president to engage his rivals directly instead of invoking Kenyatta.

The dispute over the SGR project's costs and the World Bank report's findings has escalated tensions between Ruto's administration and the opposition. Ruto's comments have also sparked a debate about the project's viability and the role of the previous administration in its implementation. Key points include:

Key points

  • The World Bank report estimates that Kenya overpaid by as much as KSh117 billion for the SGR project.
  • Ruto's administration has insisted that the report's findings are being misinterpreted by the opposition.
  • The SGR project's costs have been a subject of controversy, with the opposition accusing Ruto's government of corruption.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.