The North West High Court in Mahikeng has dismissed three special pleas raised by the Minister of Police, the Director of Public Prosecutions and the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services, clearing the way for Odirile Oneboy Mmusi's civil claim to proceed. Judge President Ronald Deon Hendricks ordered the defendants to pay Mmusi's legal costs on a party-and-party basis, including the costs of employing counsel. This ruling allows Mmusi's claim to move forward.

Mmusi was arrested on May 16, 2019, in Stella, North West, and remained in detention until May 31, 2021, when the charges against him were withdrawn. During his 746 days in custody, Mmusi allegedly suffered an arbitrary deprivation of his freedom. He claims that his bail was unreasonably opposed based on allegedly false information supplied by police officers to the presiding magistrate. Mmusi also alleges that he was repeatedly not brought before court and that his matter was postponed numerous times.

The defendants raised three special pleas seeking to prevent the damages claim from proceeding. The first concerned Mmusi's alleged failure to comply with the statutory requirements for notifying organs of state of intended legal proceedings. However, the court noted that Mfenyana J had already granted condonation on August 24, 2023, for the late delivery of the notices. This effectively disposed of the first special plea.

The second special plea concerned the alleged failure to serve the summons in accordance with section 2(2)(a) of the State Liability Act. The defendants argued that the provision required strict compliance and that the failure to serve the summons on the relevant department's head was fatal to the claim. However, Judge Hendricks rejected this argument, holding that the defendants had been aware of the proceedings and had participated in them.

The third special plea concerned the fact that the criminal charges against Mmusi had been provisionally withdrawn. The defendants argued that the charges could still be reinstated and that the criminal proceedings had therefore not been finalised, making his civil claim premature. Mmusi countered that the possibility of being charged again had no bearing on the detention he had already endured.

Judge Hendricks agreed with Mmusi, finding that any future prosecution would constitute a different cause of action and would not negate the period already spent in detention. The judge concluded that all three special pleas were without merit and dismissed them with costs. This ruling does not determine whether Mmusi's arrest and detention were unlawful or whether he is entitled to the R5 million he is claiming.

The issues of whether Mmusi's arrest and detention were unlawful and whether he is entitled to the R5 million in damages remain to be decided in the main civil proceedings. Mmusi instituted the claim over his alleged unlawful arrest and detention, seeking R5 million in damages. The court's decision allows Mmusi's claim to proceed, but the outcome of the claim is still uncertain.

Key points

  • The North West High Court has dismissed three special pleas raised by the Minister of Police, the Director of Public Prosecutions and the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services.
  • Odirile Oneboy Mmusi spent 746 days in custody before charges against him were withdrawn.
  • Mmusi is seeking R5 million in damages for his alleged unlawful arrest and detention.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.