A new study released on Tuesday suggests that banning cellphones in schools can lead to small but statistically significant improvements in math and reading scores. The study, conducted by researchers at Harvard University and Dartmouth College, analyzed test scores from over 3 million elementary, middle, and high school students over the past five school years. The results show that schools that implemented locked-pouch cellphone bans saw improvements in test scores compared to similar schools that did not.
The study's authors, including Harvard's Tom Kane and Dartmouth's Douglas Staiger, found that strict cellphone bans appeared to trigger small learning gains, equivalent to 1-2 weeks of learning a year. These gains did not seem to fade out after the first year of implementation, but instead continued year after year, at least up to three years after adoption. The researchers used student-level test scores from schools that adopted phone pouches made by the company Yondr, which requires students to put their phones in locked pouches during the school day.
However, not all studies on the topic have found similar results. A separate study released in April found that these pouches had "close to zero" impact on student test scores, and if there was a benefit, it was not statistically significant. Brian Jacob, a co-author of that April study and a professor of education policy at the University of Michigan, notes that the new study's findings are encouraging, but more research is needed to confirm the results.
One key difference between the two studies is the level of data used. The April study pooled school-level mean test scores at several thousand Yondr-adopting schools, while the new study used student-level scores at 844 schools that use both Yondr pouches and tests administered by NWEA. The new study's more fine-grained data may have allowed for more precise estimates of the impact of cellphone bans on test scores.
The researchers note that the mass adoption of cell phones by children and teens coincided with declines in student test scores around 2013. Prior to 2013, math achievement among fourth- and eighth-graders had risen steadily for nearly a quarter-century, and reading scores had also improved. However, around 2013, student test scores began a sustained tumble that continued through the COVID-19 pandemic.
The study's authors argue that the cost of implementing cellphone bans, roughly $25 per student, is relatively low compared to the potential benefits. Kane notes that even small improvements in test scores can add up over time, and that the benefits of cellphone bans may be worth the cost. However, some researchers, such as Stanford University's Tom Dee, remain skeptical about the long-term impact of cellphone bans on student achievement.
The researchers plan to study students' smartphone and social media use outside of school to better understand the impact of cellphones on student learning. As the debate over cellphone bans in schools continues, this study provides new evidence that such bans can have a positive impact on student test scores. However, more research is needed to fully understand the effects of cellphone bans and to determine the best ways to implement them.
Key points
- The study found that strict cellphone bans can lead to small but statistically significant improvements in math and reading scores, equivalent to 1-2 weeks of learning a year.