Attorney Raouf Gulbul has announced that he will not be participating in the promotion exercise for Senior Counsel in Mauritius. Gulbul expressed his concerns over the current system, stating that it lacks clear criteria for selection, such as merit, competence, experience, and quality of work. He believes that the process has shifted its focus from a candidate's abilities to their connections and networks.

Gulbul's main objection lies in the principle of sponsorship required for a candidate's application to be considered. He argues that an attorney's competence and reputation should be the primary factors in their evaluation, not their connections or relationships. This, he believes, could lead to a system where candidates are judged on who they know rather than their professional abilities.

The attorney also raised concerns over the potential for a network-based system, where candidates with influential connections may have an unfair advantage. He emphasized that a merit-based system is essential for the legal profession, where independence and objectivity are crucial. Gulbul's decision not to participate in the promotion exercise was not taken lightly, but he feels that the current system undermines the values of the legal profession.

Gulbul's concerns are shared by others, including Kailash Trilochun, who has contested the process in court. While Gulbul refrained from commenting on the ongoing court case, he acknowledged that the controversy surrounding the promotion system warrants attention and consideration. He emphasized that a transparent and fair system is essential for the integrity of the legal profession.

The current promotion system has been criticized for its lack of transparency, with many questioning the criteria used to evaluate candidates. Gulbul stressed that a clear and coherent process is necessary to ensure that candidates are judged fairly and that the public has confidence in the system. He believes that the legal profession should be guided by principles of equity and fairness.

Gulbul's decision not to participate in the promotion exercise is a reflection of his commitment to the values of the legal profession. As a veteran attorney with years of experience, he hopes that his concerns will be heard and that the system will be re-examined. He emphasized that change is possible and that correcting the system's flaws is essential for the integrity of the profession.

The controversy surrounding the Senior Counsel promotion system in Mauritius highlights the need for a fair and transparent evaluation process. Gulbul's concerns and decision not to participate serve as a reminder of the importance of upholding the values of the legal profession. The outcome of the court case and the response from the authorities will be closely watched by the legal community and the public.

Key points

  • Attorney Raouf Gulbul declines Senior Counsel promotion due to concerns over merit-based selection and transparency.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.