The Young Queer Alliance recently presented a socio-economic study on equal access to civil marriage, commissioned to Mauritian doctoral student and human rights activist Lakshita Kanhiya. The research reveals that the exclusion of same-sex couples from civil marriage in Mauritius results in structural legal and socio-economic disadvantages. These disadvantages affect property, inheritance, pensions, employment, taxation, housing, immigration, family responsibilities, and social protection.
The study, presented at the Gold Crest hotel, was attended by Michael Gyan Nyarko, an international human rights jurist, and Sandy Christ Bhaganooa, a Mauritian lawyer practicing in Paris and Mauritius. They provided insights into the legal implications of same-sex marriage and its recognition in other countries. The study notes that while Mauritius has strengthened legal protections for LGBTQIA+ individuals through laws like the Equal Opportunities Act of 2008 and the Workers' Rights Act of 2019, these protections do not translate to complete legal recognition of same-sex relationships.
The Supreme Court of Mauritius has interpreted the ban on discrimination based on "sex" in the Constitution to include "sexual orientation," effectively decriminalizing intimate relationships between adult men in private. However, this has not led to the recognition of same-sex marriages. In practice, same-sex couples are still unable to enter into civil marriages in Mauritius, despite the main legislative provisions governing marriage eligibility not explicitly requiring opposite sexes.
The lack of recognition for same-sex marriage affects various aspects of life, including property, inheritance, and wealth accumulation. Civil marriage provides a legal framework for managing marital property and asset distribution, which same-sex couples are denied. This can lead to housing insecurity, disputes over jointly acquired assets, and difficulties in preserving wealth after death.
The study also highlights the impact on pensions, social security, and survivor benefits. Same-sex partners may be excluded from these benefits, despite shared financial responsibilities and economic dependence. Furthermore, employment rights and family benefits, such as employer-provided health insurance, parental leave, and professional pensions, are not accessible to same-sex households.
The absence of marital recognition also affects access to tax benefits, housing programs, and financial protections. Immigration and transnational family protection are also complicated for same-sex couples, particularly when one partner is a foreign national or when the marriage was legally contracted abroad. This can impact the security of residence, job continuity, and family unity.
Ultimately, the lack of legal recognition for same-sex marriage in Mauritius denies same-sex partners access to essential mechanisms for financial support and family protection. This includes pension and financial adjustments available to recognized spouses. The study emphasizes the need for comprehensive legal recognition of same-sex relationships to address these socio-economic disadvantages.
Key points
- The study was conducted by Lakshita Kanhiya, a Mauritian doctoral student and human rights activist.
- The research highlights the need for comprehensive legal recognition of same-sex relationships in Mauritius.
- The exclusion of same-sex couples from civil marriage results in structural legal and socio-economic disadvantages.