Researchers have found that mass mobilisation, historically seen as a viable path to democracy, has had varying degrees of success in achieving democratic change. In a 120-year study, they examined how mass mobilisation influenced the likelihood of democratic transitions. The study, conducted by researchers including Kristian Skrede Gleditsch and Gudmund Hermansen, reveals that mass mobilisation was strongly associated with democratisation and regime change during a "golden age" from the early 1980s until roughly the Arab Spring in 2011.

During this golden age, many authoritarian regimes yielded to domestic and international pressure, resulting in democratic change. Examples include the fall of Ferdinand Marcos in Manila in 1986, the collapse of the Berlin Wall in 1989, and the demise of South Africa's apartheid regime in the 1990s. However, before and after this golden age, the relationship between mass mobilisation and democratic change is less clear-cut. The study finds no detectable relationship between mass mobilisation and democratic change before 1980 and after 2011.

The study reveals that before 1980, mass mobilisation made rulers more likely to fall, but the regimes that fell were not systematically replaced by democracies. The 1974 revolution in Ethiopia is cited as an example, where mass protests and strikes contributed to the overthrow of Haile Selassie, only to be replaced by a military dictatorship. In contrast, from the Arab Spring through 2019, mass mobilisation is no longer systematically associated with regime collapse. Authoritarian regimes have managed to remain in power despite extensive mobilisation.

The researchers combined data on protest campaigns demanding democratic change to classify countries as democracies or autocracies in each year. They focused only on autocracies, examining whether mass mobilisation increased the likelihood of a transition to democracy. The study used statistical models that allowed the effect of mass mobilisation to vary over time, rather than assuming it remained constant. The findings suggest that the power of mass mobilisation to bring about democratic change has shifted dramatically over time.

Despite exceptionally high levels of popular mobilisation, the fact that it no longer has the same democratising effect helps explain how a wave of protest can coincide with the current authoritarian wave. The study suggests that several factors may contribute to this shift, including the rise of social media, large demonstrations, and smart repression. Authoritarian regimes may have become better at responding to challenges from the street, and the international climate may have also played a role.

The researchers note that their study does not conclusively test these explanations, but they suggest that the rise and fall in the effectiveness of mass mobilisation is unlikely to be explained by any single factor. The study's findings have implications for understanding the development of democracy in the modern era. The impact of mass mobilisation has moved in cycles, and it remains to be seen whether the pendulum has started to swing back.

The study's results are based on an analysis of data up to 2019, and the researchers note that they do not know whether the weak relationship they observe at the end of the period has persisted or whether the pendulum has started to swing back. Since 2019, several important victories for mass mobilisation have been reported, including in Bangladesh. Further research is needed to understand the current and future impact of mass mobilisation on democratisation.

Key points

  • Mass mobilisation was strongly associated with democratisation and regime change during a "golden age" from the early 1980s until roughly the Arab Spring in 2011.
  • Before 1980, mass mobilisation made rulers more likely to fall, but the regimes that fell were not systematically replaced by democracies.
  • The power of mass mobilisation to bring about democratic change has shifted dramatically over time, with no detectable relationship between mass mobilisation and democratic change before 1980 and after 2011.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.