The trial of Loft & Keys Limited CEO, Austin Albert, has suffered another setback at the Federal High Court in Lagos. A private prosecutor, R.A. Atuwayin, admitted to not having obtained the Attorney-General of the Federation's (AGF) authorisation to prosecute the case. This development has raised concerns over the legal basis for the prosecution. The case was filed by the office of the Inspector-General of Police (IGP) against Albert and Jinadu Musbau Olalekan.
The police had earlier withdrawn the charge, prompting questions from the defence over the legal authority for the continued prosecution. At the October 5, 2026 sitting, police prosecutor Inspector G.T. Nev informed the court of the withdrawal of the amended charge. Following this, the Federal Government announced its intention to take over the prosecution, but the case file had not been received, leading to an adjournment.
The private prosecutor's admission has sparked concerns from the defence over the legal basis for his appearance. Section 174(1) of the 1999 Constitution empowers the AGF to institute, take over, and discontinue criminal proceedings in federal courts. Section 106 of the Administration of Criminal Justice Act (ACJA) 2015 provides for the authority required for private legal practitioners to conduct criminal prosecutions.
The defence has questioned the circumstances surrounding the institution of the charge, alleging that Albert was not invited by the police to respond to allegations before being charged. The defence argued that Albert was not given an opportunity to make a statement, submit relevant documents, or call witnesses during the investigation. They claim this omission raises questions about compliance with constitutional guarantees of fair hearing and presumption of innocence.
The defence cited previous judicial decisions, maintaining that criminal proceedings should not be deployed to settle private disputes or exert pressure on individuals. They also questioned the continued prosecution of the case following the police's withdrawal of the charge and the absence of established authorisation for the private prosecutor.
The case has prominent legal representation, with Ebun-Olu Adegboruwa (SAN) appearing for Albert and Mallam Adio representing the second defendant. Mr Oluniyi Adedeji appeared for the nominal complainant, Ms Jane Kimemia, while Ms Ogechi Abu represented the International Federation of Women Lawyers (FIDA). The presiding judge, Justice Ibrahim Ahmad Kala, adjourned the matter until January 13, 2027.
The trial's progression remains uncertain, with key concerns over the legal authority for the prosecution. The case highlights the importance of adhering to constitutional and legal requirements in the prosecution of criminal cases. The next hearing will likely address the issues raised, determining the future course of the trial.
Key points
- The trial of Loft & Keys CEO Austin Albert stalls due to the private prosecutor's admission of lacking the AGF's fiat.
- The defence questions the legal basis for the prosecution and the circumstances surrounding the institution of the charge.
- The case has been adjourned until January 13, 2027, with its progression uncertain.