The renewal of contracts for eight principal secretaries in Lesotho has sparked a heated debate in Parliament, with opposition MPs questioning the legality of the extensions. The Tenth Amendment to the Constitution Act, 2025, abolished the office of Principal Secretary, introducing the position of Permanent Secretary instead. MPs argue that the extensions were unlawful because the amendment required existing PSs to either retire or continue serving under the new constitutional framework through a transparent recruitment process.
The issue was raised by 'Machabana Lemphane-Letsie, leader of HOPE-Mphatlalatsane, who filed a question in the National Assembly seeking to establish how many PSs' contracts had expired since the enactment of the Tenth Amendment. She also wanted to know how many contracts had been extended, for how long, and under which legal framework. The Tenth Amendment was gazetted on 13 August 2025 as the first set of constitutional reforms to emerge from the national reforms process.
The amendment re-designates principal secretaries as permanent secretaries, placing them under the Government Secretary and empowering the Public Service Commission (PSC) to appoint them. However, the government appears to have applied the new constitutional dispensation selectively, having appointed Mpopo Tšoele as "permanent secretary" in the Ministry of Local Government, Chieftainship, Home Affairs and Police in January 2026.
In response, Minister of Public Service Moeketsi Motšoane told Parliament that the contracts of 12 PSs had expired after the Tenth Amendment came into force. He said these were the PS in the Prime Minister's Office, the ministries of Labour and Employment, Law and Justice, Public Service, Foreign Affairs and International Relations, Local Government and Chieftainship, Education and Training, Information, Communications, Science, Technology and Innovation, Security Services, Natural Resources, Environment and Forestry, and Health.
Motšoane explained that only eight PSs' contracts had been renewed, with the contract for the Office of the Prime Minister extended for three months, from 17 January to 16 April 2026. The contracts of the PSs for the ministries of Public Service, Foreign Affairs and International Relations, Local Government and Chieftainship, Education and Training, Information, Communications, Science, Technology and Innovation, and Natural Resources were extended until those positions are filled with new PSs.
Lemphane-Letsie asked a supplementary question, requesting Motšoane to explain how a contract for a position abolished by the Tenth Amendment could be extended in terms of an old provision. She pointed out that the minister had relied on Section 139 (1) and (2) of the "old" Constitution, yet the contracts were extended after the enactment of the Tenth Amendment, which ended the position of Principal Secretary and introduced that of Permanent Secretary.
Motšoane replied that the PSs were employed under the original Constitution and that nothing had changed, citing Section 139, which states that the power to appoint a person to hold or act in any office to which this section applies shall vest in the Prime Minister, acting after consultation with the Public Service Commission. The debate highlights the challenges of implementing constitutional reforms and the need for clarity on the legal framework governing public service appointments.
Key points
- Opposition MPs question the legality of contract extensions for principal secretaries under the Tenth Amendment.
- The Tenth Amendment abolished the office of Principal Secretary, introducing the position of Permanent Secretary.
- The government has selectively applied the new constitutional dispensation, appointing some permanent secretaries under the new framework.
Reporting sources
- Uproar over PSs’ contract renewals · Lesotho Times website