Labour analysts in South Africa have come out to say that foreign nationals should not be blamed for dominating entry-level jobs in various sectors. This statement comes after a report by the department of employment and labour’s Inspection and Enforcement Services (IES) found that 231,850 foreign nationals were employed in 21,371 workplaces inspected by the end of the second quarter of the 2026/27 financial year. The report was released amid nationwide protests by anti-illegal migration groups.
The protests, led by activist Jacinta Ngobese-Zuma and others, called for undocumented foreign nationals to leave the country, accusing them of "stealing" South Africans' jobs. The protests resulted in violence, intimidation, and looting in KwaZulu-Natal and Gauteng, prompting government intervention. President Cyril Ramaphosa stressed that enforcing immigration laws was the state's responsibility and warned against individuals demanding documentation or proof of nationality.
According to IES inspector-general Aggy Moiloa, most foreign nationals were employed in entry-level jobs that could have been occupied by South Africans. Moiloa was speaking at the department's strategic planning conference in Rustenburg. He added that agriculture had the most foreign nationals, employing 46,533 across 1,205 employers, followed by wholesale and retail, which employed 41,359 across 6,698 employers.
South Africa is currently battling a high joblessness rate of 33.7%, with 8.6 million people unemployed. The expanded unemployment rate, which includes discouraged job seekers, stands at 44%, one of the highest in the world. Moiloa said the top 10 sectors employing foreign nationals included community, manufacturing, hospitality, mining, private security, financial services, and education.
Labour analyst and DA spokesperson on employment and labour, Michael Bagraim, said all workers in the country were entitled to constitutionally enshrined rights, regardless of nationality. However, he added that if a foreigner was in the country illegally, they had no rights and should be deported. Bagraim also criticized the employment and labour department for giving work permits to foreign nationals for menial jobs that South Africans could do.
In June, President Ramaphosa announced that the government would intensify deportations of undocumented foreign nationals, recruit more labour inspectors, strengthen border security, and introduce employment quotas as part of a comprehensive overhaul of South Africa's immigration system. The government has identified illegal immigration as a significant challenge, with implications for social cohesion, national security, and service provision.
Law enforcement agencies are intensifying the identification and deportation of undocumented foreigners, supported by dedicated immigration courts. The department of employment and labour is recruiting 10,000 inspectors, and penalties for employers that contravene the Immigration Act will be strengthened. Labour analyst Mojalefa Musi said the matter was concerning, given the high unemployment rate, but noted that the nature of work emerging was not attractive to average South Africans.
Key points
- Foreign nationals are not responsible for South Africa's jobs crisis, according to labour analysts.
- The government is intensifying deportations of undocumented foreign nationals and recruiting more labour inspectors.
- South Africa's unemployment rate stands at 33.7%, with 8.6 million people unemployed.