Manchester United officially parted ways with manager Michael Carrick on November 12, 2026, following a disappointing start to the 2026/27 season. The team languished in 18th position in the Premier League table. Carrick's managerial credentials have been questioned by former Liverpool star Jamie Carragher. Carragher expressed his thoughts on Carrick's appointment, stating that he feels no sympathy for the 45-year-old.
Carragher argued that Carrick was fortunate to receive the prestigious appointment, citing his thin managerial resume. He mentioned that Carrick got the job primarily due to his legendary 12-year playing career at Manchester United. Carragher stated, "Michael Carrick got the job on the back of nothing. He got the job on the back of basically playing for Man United." He also noted that Carrick had only about two years of managerial experience at Middlesbrough before taking the Manchester United job.
Prior to joining Manchester United, Carrick's only permanent managerial experience was at Championship side Middlesbrough between October 2022 and June 2025. He initially returned to Manchester United as an interim head coach in January 2026, replacing Ruben Amorim. Carrick successfully led the club to a third-place finish and UEFA Champions League qualification. Carragher acknowledged Carrick's initial success, highlighting his tactical victories over key rivals.
Despite his initial success, Carrick failed to sustain momentum, presiding over a systemic collapse during the opening months of the current season. His final matches included a difficult UEFA Champions League fixture against Roma and a chaotic 4-4 Premier League draw against Aston Villa. Carragher noted that while Carrick had some successes, his overall performance was not at the level required for a Premier League manager.
Carragher concluded that Carrick was not at the calibre of managers in the Premier League, stating, "The managers in the Premier League are the best in the world and he's just not quite at that level." He also mentioned that the fans chanting Carrick's name as he departed the touchline was not enough to justify his continued tenure. Manchester United have since turned their attention to former United States Men's National Team manager Mauricio Pochettino.
Carragher's comments have sparked discussion about Carrick's managerial abilities and his treatment by Manchester United. The former Liverpool star's assessment of Carrick's credentials has been shared widely, with many fans and pundits weighing in on the debate. Carrick's future in football management remains uncertain following his dismissal from Manchester United.
The sacking of Michael Carrick has raised questions about the club's decision-making process and the expectations placed on managers. Manchester United's attention has turned to Mauricio Pochettino, who will be tasked with salvaging the fractured campaign. The team's performance will be closely watched in the coming weeks as they aim to improve their standings in the Premier League and UEFA Champions League.
Key points
- Jamie Carragher questioned Michael Carrick's managerial credentials, stating that he feels no sympathy for the 45-year-old following his dismissal from Manchester United.
