A recent report titled "Manufacturing The Great Replacement" has uncovered an influence operation linked to entities based in Israel that allegedly spent an estimated $8.2 million promoting anti-Muslim conspiracy theories across more than 30 countries. The campaign, which ran from October 2023 to October 2026, generated an estimated 800 million advertising exposures across Europe, the Americas, Asia, and the Middle East.
The report described the operation as "one of the largest influence and disinformation campaigns ever documented." It found that the campaign spread racist, anti-Muslim, anti-migrant, anti-Qatar, and anti-Iran narratives through various means, including social media advertisements, AI-generated videos, music, video game parodies, and repurposed footage. The campaign promoted the Great Replacement, a debunked white nationalist conspiracy theory claiming that migration and demographic changes are deliberately replacing white Europeans with nonwhite populations.
One campaign, titled "Grand Theft Qatar," depicted Emiratis buying European buildings and converting them into mosques. Other advertisements featured slogans such as "THIS IS AN INVASION" and "QATAR IS ISLAMISING EUROPE." Researchers Marc Owen Jones and Sohan Dsouza conducted the investigation, tracing the operation to Israel-linked entities. However, they could not conclusively attribute the operation to the Israeli government, stating that "the evidence shows that the entities involved in this operation are based in Israel and have connections to influence operations run by the Israeli government."
The researchers identified 1,473 Facebook advertisements, 189 YouTube videos, 359 TikTok advertisements, and 105 TikTok account videos as part of the campaign. They also examined 406 comments on Facebook advertisements targeting UK audiences in 2024, finding that 61% expressed support for Islamophobic views. Meta acknowledged in 2024 that the operation had spent $900,000 on advertisements across its platforms. The company stated that its Community Standards prohibit hate speech, harmful misinformation, deceptive behavior, and coordinated inauthentic activity.
Following enforcement action by Meta in May 2024, the operation resurfaced in November and later shifted to Brazilian corporate entities. The researchers traced the campaign's initial operations to Israel through Vietnamese proxy companies. Dsouza told The National that the investigation revealed a complex network of entities involved in the operation. The researchers called for stronger government regulation, including stricter identity verification requirements for social media advertisers and faster action against coordinated influence campaigns.
The report highlighted the need for social media companies to take more decisive action against disinformation campaigns. Meta stated that it is "constantly working to identify and disrupt coordinated inauthentic behavior." The company removed the identified advertisements and accounts for violating its Community Standards. The researchers emphasized that the campaign's impact was significant, with an estimated 800 million advertising exposures across multiple regions.
The investigation's findings have raised concerns about the spread of disinformation and the need for greater regulation of social media advertising. The researchers' recommendations for stricter identity verification requirements and faster action against coordinated influence campaigns are expected to be taken into consideration by governments and social media companies.
Key points
- The campaign promoted the Great Replacement, a debunked white nationalist conspiracy theory.
- The operation was traced to Israel-linked entities, but not conclusively attributed to the Israeli government.
- The campaign generated an estimated 800 million advertising exposures across multiple regions.