On November 16, Germany, Austria, Denmark, Greece, and the Netherlands presented a plan to establish an asylum center in Rwanda for asylum seekers whose appeals have been rejected. The center is expected to accommodate around 100 people who will receive a Rwandan residence permit. The UN High Commissioner for Human Rights and Human Rights Watch have expressed concerns about the plan. If the pilot project is successful, the five countries may extend it to other states, including Uganda and Uzbekistan.

The proposed center is not intended to serve as a deterrent for asylum seekers, according to Catherine Wihtol de Wenden, a migration specialist and teacher at CERI Sciences Po. She believes that the center's impact will be limited, given the large number of asylum seekers and the fact that the center will only have 100 places. The European Union has taken around 500,000 return decisions in 2025, with 27% of them not being executed. Wihtol de Wenden argues that the center is more of a symbolic gesture than a practical solution.

The center is part of a broader shift in European migration policy, driven in part by electoral considerations and the rise of far-right movements. Countries like Germany, which had previously been known for its welcoming policy towards refugees, are now adopting more restrictive approaches. The Danish government had previously negotiated with Rwanda to establish a similar center, and the Netherlands has also joined the project.

The plan has been met with skepticism by some, who argue that it does not address the root causes of migration and may not be effective in deterring asylum seekers. The center's impact on the migration business and the humanitarian situation of asylum seekers remains to be seen. According to Frontex, there has been a decrease in asylum seekers arriving in Europe this year, but this may be due to the fact that many asylum seekers are now seeking refuge in neighboring countries.

The choice of Rwanda as a partner country has raised questions about the benefits for the African nation. According to Wihtol de Wenden, Rwanda's image on the international scene had been tarnished recently due to its support for the M23 rebellion, and partnering with European countries may be seen as a way to regain credibility.

The proposed asylum center in Rwanda is not an isolated incident, as the UK had previously considered a similar plan. The European Union's migration policy has been criticized for its reliance on deterrence and externalization of border controls. The effectiveness of the center in addressing the complexities of migration remains to be seen.

The project has sparked debate about the future of European migration policy and the role of third countries in managing asylum seekers. While some see the center as a necessary measure to address the migration crisis, others argue that it may not be effective in addressing the root causes of migration and may lead to further humanitarian crises.

Key points

  • The proposed asylum center in Rwanda has sparked concerns about its effectiveness and impact on migration.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.