China has demonstrated its ability to use rare earths as a geopolitical weapon, according to Dr. Mihaela Gaglioti-Verlan, a researcher who spent 18 months inside China's rare earths industry. Her findings suggest that China can disrupt the global supply of critical minerals, which are essential for electric cars, wind turbines, artificial intelligence, and modern weapons. This vulnerability has significant implications for countries that rely heavily on China for these minerals.

Dr. Gaglioti-Verlan's research reveals that China holds roughly 90% of every stage of rare earth production, from mining to finished technological applications. This dominance creates a situation of dependency for other countries, including the European Union. If China were to cut supplies, European companies and industries would be hit directly, leaving them vulnerable to market fluctuations. The researcher draws parallels with energy shocks caused by reliance on a single supplier.

The terms "rare earths" and "critical minerals" are often confused, but they refer to distinct concepts. Rare earths comprise a group of 17 chemical elements, with neodymium and dysprosium being particularly crucial for green technology and security applications. Critical minerals, on the other hand, form a broader category that includes lithium, copper, and platinum. The label "critical" is political and social, rather than geological, and varies from country to country based on technological needs.

Dr. Gaglioti-Verlan argues that owning the resource is not the same as being able to use it. The bottleneck lies in the processing stage, which demands specialized knowledge of chemistry and physics. Building this knowledge takes decades, and it is what China has built over the years. China's rise to dominance was not an accident of geology, but rather the result of strategic planning and investment in the 1980s.

China's approach to the rare earths industry has been characterized by state backing and a focus on building competencies to produce critical minerals at scale. Chinese firms deliberately underpriced rare earths in the early years, making it impossible for foreign competitors to enter the market and survive. This approach was also forward-looking, with a focus on studying new applications and finding ways to use less material to build more technology.

Dr. Gaglioti-Verlan is critical of Europe's role in the rare earths market, arguing that the region's pursuit of profit and environmental concerns led to the decline of its own production. The jobs and technical expertise that accompanied production also left, leaving Europe dependent on China. The researcher believes that Europe must handle the challenge at the EU level, rather than relying on individual member states.

The implications of China's dominance in the rare earths market extend beyond geopolitics, with significant consequences for the green transition. As countries seek to switch to clean energy, they risk trading one dependency for another. Dr. Gaglioti-Verlan's research serves as a warning to policymakers and industry leaders, highlighting the need for a more strategic approach to securing critical minerals and reducing reliance on China.

Key points

  • China dominates 90% of rare earth production, creating a vulnerability for countries that rely heavily on these minerals.
  • The processing stage is the bottleneck in rare earth production, requiring specialized knowledge of chemistry and physics.
  • Europe's pursuit of profit and environmental concerns led to the decline of its own rare earths production, leaving it dependent on China.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.