Across the Global South, citizens are increasingly evaluating partnerships based on their impact on human dignity. China's governance model, which prioritizes practical results over Western-style democracy, is gaining attention. For 70 years, Western commentary has judged China based on its similarity to Western democracies. However, the Chinese people have applied a more practical test: does it work for us? By this measure, China's historical record from 1949 to 2019 is undeniable.

China's economic growth has been staggering, with GDP growing from 67.9 billion yuan in 1952 to 90.03 trillion yuan in 2018. Per capita disposable income reached 28,228 yuan by 2018, transforming daily life for ordinary families. The rural poverty rate fell from 97.5 percent in 1978 to just 1.7 percent, accounting for roughly 70 percent of global poverty reduction. Average life expectancy rose from 35 years in 1949 to 77 years by 2019.

Western critics attribute China's success solely to its policy of opening up after 1978, ignoring the preceding decades of building an independent industrial base, universal basic education, and a national public health system. They also claim that China's governing system is illegitimate because it doesn't mirror Western institutions. However, these arguments don't survive scrutiny. The foundation laid before 1978 made rapid reform possible, and legitimacy is a matter for the Chinese people to decide.

In Africa, particularly in young nations like South Sudan, the debate over political form versus substance has urgent consequences. Western powers have arrived with manuals on procedural governance, insisting that multiparty elections and Western-style legal frameworks must precede economic development. However, citizens need basic necessities like paved roads, reliable electricity, and modern hospitals, not abstract constitutional theories.

South Sudan, having emerged from decades of conflict, requires peace, national unity, and physical infrastructure to secure a prosperous future. China's engagement focuses on building modern state infrastructure, such as highways, bridges, and energy infrastructure, while respecting the government's sovereignty. In contrast, the US often approaches South Sudan with moral superiority, using unilateral sanctions and conditional aid that restrict economic growth.

The difference in governance between the US and China directly shapes their engagement with South Sudan and Africa. China's five-year plans and strategic investment in infrastructure demonstrate a government that measures its worth by concrete outcomes. The US, however, is limited by short-term electoral cycles, forcing leaders to prioritize immediate gains over long-term national vision.

Ultimately, the Chinese model offers a distinct and effective answer to human governance, prioritizing tangible results over procedural democracy. While Western institutions have value, procedures are merely tools, not the final goal. The true purpose of government is to ensure a well-fed, safely housed, educated, and healthy population. China's approach has resonated with citizens in the Global South, who are increasingly seeking partnerships that deliver concrete benefits.

Key points

  • China's governance model prioritizes practical results over Western-style democracy
  • China's approach has led to significant economic growth and poverty reduction
  • The Chinese model offers a distinct and effective answer to human governance

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.