The Executive Director of the Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA), Sulemana Braimah, has expressed concerns that the Attorney-General's directive on protecting the rights of arrested persons may not yield desired results without effective enforcement. He made these comments on JoyNews' Newsfile on Saturday, November 21. According to Braimah, although the directive reinforces important constitutional and legal safeguards, its success depends on whether law enforcement agencies translate the requirements into their daily operations.
The Attorney-General's directive requires law enforcement and investigative agencies, including the Ghana Police Service, the Economic and Organised Crime Office (EOCO), the National Intelligence Bureau (NIB), and the Narcotics Control Commission (NACOC), to comply with the constitutional 48-hour detention limit and other safeguards protecting suspects. The directive also requires arrested persons to be informed of the reasons for their arrest and their right to legal representation.
Braimah welcomed the directive, describing decisions aimed at promoting and protecting people's rights as fundamental. However, he questioned why law enforcement agencies had, over the years, failed to consistently uphold requirements that were already captured in existing laws. He emphasized that the real achievement would be seen when citizens begin to experience improved protection of their rights in their dealings with law enforcement agencies.
The directive prohibits the use of arrest and detention to recover civil debts, unlawful searches, torture, and coercion. It also requires law enforcement agencies to respect suspects' right to silence and ensure that confessions are voluntary. Furthermore, the agencies are required to submit quarterly compliance reports to the Attorney-General detailing arrests, releases, court appearances, and alleged rights violations.
Braimah warned against allowing the directive to become another official declaration that generates public expectations without producing tangible changes. He argued that the challenge is whether the directive will be one of those usual things where nice policy statements are made, but at the end of the day, nothing changes. He stressed that meaningful acknowledgement would only be justified when its implementation began to produce visible results for the protection of citizens' rights.
Braimah acknowledged that enforcing the requirements could prove more difficult in practice than it appeared on paper, making sustained commitment from the affected institutions essential. He drew a comparison with political party manifestoes, saying governments often presented attractive promises and policies but failed to deliver the expected changes after assuming office.
The Attorney-General's directive should be judged by its practical outcomes rather than the announcement itself, according to Braimah. He emphasized that while the directive deserved recognition, its success would depend on the effective enforcement of its provisions. The implementation of the directive will be crucial in determining its impact on the protection of suspects' rights in Ghana.
Key points
- The Attorney-General's directive on suspects' rights must be effectively enforced to produce meaningful results.
- The directive requires law enforcement agencies to comply with the constitutional 48-hour detention limit and other safeguards protecting suspects.
- The success of the directive will depend on sustained commitment from the affected institutions.