The Western Cape High Court has ruled in favour of the City of Cape Town, ordering Mowbray resident Brent Bonnes to demolish unlawful building works at his property within 60 days. The court found that the City did not grant approval for a second storey and two ground-floor dwelling units. Judge Nobahle Mangcu-Lockwood made the order last week, resolving a dispute that began with Bonnes' construction of a second storey without obtaining approval.

Bonnes had bought the property in 2008 and obtained approval to construct a boundary wall and a double garage in May 2016. However, he added the second storey to the dwelling without obtaining approval, prompting the City to serve him with notices to stop the unauthorised works and to obtain the necessary written approval. The City had demanded conversion of the ground floor into a single dwelling unit within 30 days for contravening a by-law regarding the existence of more than one dwelling unit on the ground floor.

Bonnes challenged the City's decision, denying that the ground floor units constituted two separate units and claiming that the City had created a legitimate expectation that his property could be regularised via a rezoning and departures application. He also claimed that he paid an administrative penalty of R30,000. However, Judge Mangcu-Lockwood dismissed his reliance on the payment of an administrative penalty and found no basis to conclude that the decision of the City was irrational or unreasonable.

The court papers stated that the building works at the centre of the dispute were a second storey unit to the single dwelling on the property and a second storey located above a double garage. Judge Mangcu-Lockwood said Bonnes was required to obtain approval in terms of the by-law, which prohibits using land contrary to the City's zoning scheme without approval. The judge found that the second storey and two ground-floor dwelling units were built unlawfully.

Judge Mangcu-Lockwood ruled that no building plan approval was granted by the City for the building works of the second storey and two ground-floor dwelling units. She interdicted and restrained Bonnes from using the two ground floor dwelling units as self-catering units or otherwise using the ground floor of the property as more than one dwelling unit. The judge ordered Bonnes to demolish the unlawful building works and to restore the property to the approved building plan within 60 days.

If Bonnes fails to comply with the order, the City may, with the assistance of other entities, demolish the building works. The court's decision was based on the finding that Bonnes failed to identify the provisions in the Promotion of Administrative Justice Act or in any other law he invoked to review the City's decision. The City had sought an order for the demolition of certain building works of Bonnes' property, while he had applied for a review of the council's decision to refuse his application for rezoning and related departures.

The court's ruling brings an end to a long-standing dispute between Bonnes and the City of Cape Town. The City had been seeking an order for the demolition of the unlawful building works, and the court's decision ensures that the property is restored to its approved state. Bonnes had been required to demolish the unlawful building works and restore the property within 60 days of the court order, failing which the City may take action.

Key points

  • The Western Cape High Court has ordered Brent Bonnes to demolish unlawful building works at his Mowbray property within 60 days.
  • The court found that the City of Cape Town did not grant approval for a second storey and two ground-floor dwelling units.
  • The court's decision ensures that the property is restored to its approved state, in accordance with the City's zoning scheme.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.