Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky revealed a proposal from the US that would involve Ukraine withdrawing its forces from the Donbass region in eastern Ukraine in exchange for NATO membership. This proposal was reportedly discussed by US envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner as part of the Trump administration's efforts to end the conflict. The conflict in Ukraine is considered the most significant land war in Europe since 1945.
NATO membership is a key strategic goal for Ukraine, offering a credible guarantee against potential future Russian attacks. Russian President Vladimir Poutine has cited NATO's expansion as justification for his policies towards Ukraine. Zelensky stated that the US posed a question: would Ukraine be willing to join NATO if it ceded the Donbass region? He indicated that he would be open to submitting a concrete proposal to a popular referendum if it included genuine security guarantees and necessary funding for reconstruction.
This proposal marks a notable shift in Ukraine's stance, as it has previously refused to cede any part of its sovereign territory. However, the potential counterpoint of NATO membership could provide a significant strategic advantage for Ukraine. The main concern is whether Moscow would be willing to accept such an arrangement. Russia has consistently opposed the presence of NATO forces on Ukrainian territory and seeks to reshape the European security architecture to reduce NATO's defensive capabilities.
The proposal poses a double risk for Ukraine, according to The Telegraph. Russia could take control of the Donbass defensive belt, one of the Ukrainian army's strongest military positions, and then find a new pretext to block Ukraine's NATO membership. In this scenario, Ukraine could lose its most fortified defensive lines without obtaining genuine security guarantees against a new Russian attack.
The primary dilemma lies in the fact that ceding territory would be a concrete and immediate concession, while promises of future security would remain without real value if not accompanied by binding and enforceable guarantees. The 1994 Budapest Memorandum, which included security commitments to Ukraine in exchange for its nuclear disarmament, serves as a relevant precedent.
Zelensky emphasized that any proposal would need to be submitted to a popular referendum, provided it includes genuine security guarantees, does not impose restrictions on Ukrainian armed forces, and provides necessary funding for reconstruction. This proposal has sparked controversy, with concerns about the potential risks and benefits of such an arrangement.
The Ukrainian president's openness to discussing this proposal reflects the complexities of the conflict and the challenges of finding a peaceful resolution. The international community will be closely watching developments, as the fate of Ukraine and the security architecture of Europe hang in the balance.
Key points
- Ukraine's potential NATO membership in exchange for ceding Donbass territory.
- Russia's opposition to NATO presence on Ukrainian territory.
- The need for binding security guarantees for Ukraine.
Reporting sources
- Donbass contre adhésion à l’OTAN : Washington évoque un échange territorial · Le Progrès Egyptien