In his analysis, barrister Peter Magomu Mashate posits that understanding Uganda's present governance requires confronting its past. He notes that the country's history with executive fiat and rule by decree has significantly shaped its governance. This period of rule by decree began in February 1966 and lasted until October 8, 1995, when the 1995 Constitution was promulgated. During this time, governance evolved through distinct political phases before being dismantled by modern constitutional architecture.
The genesis of rule by decree in Uganda is traced back to February 1966, during the Mengo Crisis, when Prime Minister Milton Obote suspended the 1962 Independence Constitution and assumed all state powers. This period saw the imposition of the interim "Pigeonhole" Constitution without parliamentary debate. Even after the 1967 Republican Constitution restored a nominal Parliament, governance relied heavily on emergency powers and executive decrees. The most absolute form of rule by decree arrived on January 25, 1971, when Major General Idi Amin seized power.
Throughout its history, rule by decree in Uganda has been justified as a necessary measure to bypass political gridlock and restore order. However, the reality has been that it birthed arbitrary governance, enabling laws passed on personal whims without public scrutiny. Regimes claimed that decrees would break factional paralysis and facilitate economic restructuring. Instead, it led to the destruction of negotiated consensus, collapsed institutional legitimacy, and deepened sectarian resentment.
The distinction between the "Rule of Law" and "rule by law" is crucial in understanding the implications of executive fiat. While rule by law uses legal instruments as weapons to enforce personal will, the true Rule of Law demands transparent, representative lawmaking adjudicated by an independent judiciary. Even if a benevolent ruler issues a decree with a socially beneficial outcome, the process itself violates the Rule of Law due to the lack of democratic legitimacy and institutional accountability.
The 1995 Constitution of Uganda was engineered as a direct antidote to governance by fiat. Four entrenched pillars - Constitutional Supremacy, Ban on Unconstitutional Takeovers, Exclusive Legislative Authority, and Strict Emergency Limits - ensure that rule by decree cannot coexist with the Constitution. Any decree or executive action inconsistent with the Constitution is automatically null and void.
Uganda's superior courts have consistently enforced the boundary between lawful executive administration and unconstitutional rule by decree. In Nakasero Market Sitting Tenants (NAMASITE) Ltd v. Nakasero Market Sitting Vendors & Traders Ltd, the Court of Appeal held unequivocally that a presidential directive cannot override the law. This demonstrates the crucial role of the judiciary in safeguarding the Constitution.
Ultimately, the incompatibility of executive fiat with Uganda's 1995 Constitution highlights the importance of upholding the rule of law. The Constitution provides a framework for governance that prioritizes democratic legitimacy, institutional accountability, and the protection of citizens' rights. As Uganda continues to navigate its governance, it is essential to learn from its past and ensure that the principles of the Rule of Law are upheld.
Key points
- The 1995 Constitution of Uganda is incompatible with executive rule by decree.
- Rule by decree has led to arbitrary governance and erosion of institutional legitimacy in Uganda's history.
- The judiciary plays a crucial role in safeguarding the Constitution and upholding the rule of law.
Reporting sources
- THE GHOST OF THE DECREE: WHY EXECUTIVE... · nilechronicles.com