A professional rugby player from South Africa has lost a court case over his brother's luxury Jaguar. Mzwanele Richman Zito claimed the R750,000 vehicle was a gift from his brother, Andile Wiseman Zitho. However, the court found his evidence to be inconsistent and unreliable. The dispute was heard in the Free State high court last week. The judge described Mzwanele's claim as an "afterthought and a recent fabrication".
According to the court, Mzwanele and Andile had a close relationship and lived together in Andile's Bloemfontein home for several years. Andile, a regional manager at an undisclosed institution, often let Mzwanele use his vehicles without charging him. These included a Polo, two Audis, a Volkswagen Amarok, and the Jaguar. Andile had also helped Mzwanele acquire vehicles by buying them in his own name due to his brother's poor credit record.
In 2021, Andile made the Jaguar available to Mzwanele for his use. Both brothers understood that the car belonged to Andile and that Mzwanele was simply allowed to drive it. However, the dispute arose on September 28, 2023, when they changed the vehicle's registration from Andile's name to Mzwanele's. Andile claimed the change was made to avoid traffic fines incurred by his brother being issued in his name.
Mzwanele argued that his brother had previously told him he could keep the Jaguar because he loved it. He also claimed the gift was partly intended to make up for his brother having sold a Golf 7 that he considered his. However, the judge rejected this version, finding that Mzwanele had struggled to explain when and how the alleged gift was offered. His account also changed during his testimony.
The judge questioned why Mzwanele only told his lawyer about the alleged gift on the evening before he testified, after sitting in court and listening to his brother's evidence. The court found that the registration certificate in Mzwanele's name did not, on its own, prove that he owned the Jaguar. Registration under the National Road Traffic Act was not conclusive proof of ownership under common law.
The judge accepted Andile's evidence that he had bought the Jaguar and retained the original registration certificate and spare keys. The court ultimately ordered Mzwanele to return the car and sign the documents needed to transfer its registration back into his brother's name. Mzwanele was also ordered to pay the legal costs of the case, including counsel's fees.
Mzwanele had played for the Griquas and later the Cheetahs. The court ruling brings an end to the bitter family dispute over the luxury vehicle. The judge described Mzwanele's version of events as "totally improbable" and rejected it as false.
Key points
- The court found Mzwanele's evidence inconsistent and unreliable.
- The judge ordered Mzwanele to return the car and pay legal costs.
- The dispute arose over the ownership of a R750,000 Jaguar.
Reporting sources
- # 4 Court orders rugby player to return brother’s luxury car · The Sunday Times