The Labour Court of South Africa has ruled that Luxxe Clothing discriminated against a Jehovah's Witness employee, Neil Harris, after the company dismissed him for attending a five-day religious school. The court found that Luxxe Clothing failed to consider reasonable ways of accommodating Harris's religious practice, despite knowing that his request was for a religious purpose. Harris was permanently appointed as a Luxxe driver in December 2020.

According to the court, Harris's dismissal on March 6, 2023, was automatically unfair under section 187(1)(f) of the Labour Relations Act. The company was ordered to reinstate Harris within 15 days, retrospectively from the date of dismissal, without loss of remuneration and benefits. The judgment was made on November 13, 2026, arising from a claim brought by Harris with the assistance of the South African Clothing and Textile Workers Union.

Harris had requested unpaid leave to attend the Theocratic Elder School in Strand, Cape Town, from February 20 to 24, 2023. His request was declined by the company's chief operating officer, Muhammad Meyer, on February 14, 2023. Harris then decided to follow his religious convictions and did not report for work from February 20 to 24, resulting in his dismissal on March 6, 2023.

The court rejected the company's argument that it had not known the request was religious and that Harris had been fairly dismissed for refusing a direct instruction. The court found that the leave form, a phone call from a union official, and written communication made it more likely than not that the company knew the religious purpose before Harris took the leave.

Judge R Lagrange also rejected the company's argument that Harris had to prove the school was a mandatory religious obligation, saying voluntary religious practices are also protected if the belief is sincerely held and not invoked for an ulterior purpose. The judge said that once an employer knows an instruction interferes with such a practice, it must explore reasonable accommodation.

The court found that Luxxe Clothing had previously made arrangements for Muslim employees to observe religious practices, but had not extended similar engagement to Harris. The company had closed the factory on Eid and let Muslim maintenance staff leave early on Fridays for prayers on an unpaid rotation, but had not asked about Harris's school or explored whether another employee could cover his duties.

The court ultimately found that accommodating Harris's request would not have imposed undue hardship, and that the company's reliance on gross insubordination was misplaced. The true and proximate reason for Harris's dismissal was his refusal to abandon his religious practice in the face of the company's uncompromising approach.

Key points

  • The Labour Court ruled that Luxxe Clothing discriminated against Neil Harris, a Jehovah's Witness employee, for attending a five-day religious school.
  • The company was ordered to reinstate Harris within 15 days, retrospectively from the date of dismissal, without loss of remuneration and benefits.
  • The judgment highlights the importance of employers considering reasonable accommodation for employees' religious practices.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.