The South African government is considering a fiscal anchor, a binding debt or primary budget surplus target that would cap state borrowing and spending. Critics argue that this approach, aimed at reducing debt, would have devastating consequences for frontline health services and worsen the shortage of healthcare workers. The country already faces a shortage of approximately 97,000 healthcare workers, with Gauteng losing 100 nurses a month.

The proposed fiscal anchor is part of a larger strategy to reduce the public sector wage bill, which has led to early retirement packages being offered to civil servants. However, data does not indicate that workers are being replaced, suggesting that the strategy may be a headcount-reduction exercise. Voluntary packages tend to attract experienced nurses, doctors, teachers, and specialists, exacerbating the crisis in the public sector.

Gauteng's Estimates of Provincial Revenue and Expenditure show a reduction of 2,899 medical and related personnel between 2024/25 and 2025/26. Budget data analysis reveals that most provinces have fewer nurses compared to three years ago. The Director-General of Treasury, Duncan Pieterse, noted that the country has maintained a primary budget surplus for three consecutive years, but this has coincided with a severe shortage of workers in schools, hospitals, and clinics.

The real test of any budget is whether it advances or erodes constitutional rights. South Africa has only 4 doctors for every 10,000 people, less than half of the desired international benchmark of 10. The Minister of Finance admits that austerity is self-defeating, and the Treasury acknowledges that debt as a percentage of GDP is an unreliable indicator.

Parliament's Standing Committee on Finance recommended that the binding fiscal anchor should not limit fiscal policy parameters and narrow the National Treasury's fiscal policy orientation. The committee's report highlights the concern that a fiscal anchor may be incompatible with improved socioeconomic outcomes and economic growth.

The Alternative Information and Development Centre (AIDC) suggests that progressive funding mechanisms, such as those outlined in its research, could stop the erosion of constitutional rights and reduce the cost of servicing debt. The AIDC argues that the world's most unequal country cannot afford to shrink the size of the state.

As the Medium Term Budget Policy Statement (MTBPS) approaches, there is a risk that reforms may squeeze an already struggling economy further. The inflation target was lowered last year, but the US and Israel's war on Iran and the Reserve Bank's response have shown how poorly a tighter target works against inflation driven by external shocks.

Key points

  • The proposed fiscal anchor could worsen the shortage of healthcare workers in South Africa.
  • The fiscal anchor may be incompatible with improved socioeconomic outcomes and economic growth.
  • Progressive funding mechanisms could stop the erosion of constitutional rights and reduce the cost of servicing debt.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.