The South African Revenue Service (Sars) is pressing ahead with a long-standing tax dispute against Africa Cash and Carry (ACC), a major cash-and-carry retailer, over a substantial tax bill of more than R6bn. According to Sars, ACC, whose shareholders include four family trusts, devised a complex scheme to avoid paying taxes owed to the state. The tax agency has been pursuing the matter for over a decade and is seeking an order to hold Crown Mines, a related entity, accountable for ACC's tax liabilities.
The dispute centers on ACC's alleged tax evasion scheme, which involved transferring its business, including immovable assets, to Crown Mines while the legal dispute was underway. Following the transaction, ACC ceased trading, and Crown Mines continued the business using ACC's premises, employees, fixtures, accounting systems, and customers. Sars claims that ACC's directors and shareholders, who were also Crown Mines' shareholders, knew of or participated in the sale-suppression system that benefited them.
The Pretoria high court recently delivered a scathing judgment against Crown Mines and ACC, finding that they had gone to great lengths to avoid paying taxes. The court ruled that Crown Mines was incorporated to evade tax, or commit fraud, for a dishonest purpose, and as a facade to conceal the true position, namely, the evasion of ACC's tax liabilities to Sars. The court also found that ACC's shareholders and directors had attempted to defraud Sars and had established Crown Mines to escape ACC's tax liabilities.
The tax dispute between Sars and ACC began in 2009, when Sars discovered that the company was under-reporting sales using a function in its point-of-sale system that allowed figures to be manually manipulated. Sars conducted a search and seizure at ACC's premises, seizing about 74,000 documents, including sales invoices, supplier invoices, and financial records. These documents allegedly revealed ACC's tax evasion scheme, sparking a multi-year dispute with Sars.
One of the legal arguments advanced by Crown Mines and ACC was that the debt owed to Sars had prescribed. However, the court ultimately described the conduct of ACC and Crown Mines as highly objectionable and found that their resistance to the tax liability justified the court's displeasure. The court awarded punitive attorney-and-client costs, highlighting the severity of the case.
Tax experts have noted that the case has significant implications for taxpayers engaged in disputes with Sars. Richan Schwellnus from Tax Consulting SA said that restructuring a business or transferring assets while a substantial tax liability remains unresolved requires exceptional care. Sars's collection powers cannot necessarily be defeated merely by moving the economic activity into another corporate vehicle.
The outcome of the case is expected to have far-reaching consequences for the cash-rich retail industry, as Sars targets the biggest players in the sector. The tax agency is intensifying its efforts to clamp down on tax evasion and ensure compliance with tax laws. The case against ACC and Crown Mines serves as a warning to other businesses that Sars will pursue tax disputes aggressively and take punitive action against those found to be evading taxes.
Key points
- Sars is pursuing a R6.5bn tax debt from Africa Cash and Carry.
- The tax dispute between Sars and ACC spans over a decade.
- The Pretoria high court ruled that Crown Mines was incorporated to evade tax and commit fraud.