The High Court of Rwanda has granted a mother permission to sue a hospital and a doctor over the death of her daughter, which occurred over four years ago. Shillen Musyimi Mwende, acting on behalf of her late daughter Diana Mwikali, had filed an application to extend the time allowed for filing a claim. The court ruled in her favor, allowing her to pursue a medical negligence claim against Nairobi Women's Hospital and Dr. Peter Igogo.

According to the court, Ms. Mwende had first lodged a complaint with the Kenya Medical Practitioners and Dentists Council (KMPDC) and waited for the medical regulator to conclude its investigation before turning to the courts. The council delivered its decision on September 4, 2024, but the time taken to determine the complaint meant that the three-year deadline for filing a civil claim was approaching. The deadline for filing the claim fell on March 20, 2025.

Ms. Mwende argued that the delay was not deliberate, citing that she had been waiting for the council to determine her complaint and that its findings were important to the civil case she intended to file. Her lawyer urged the court to allow the application, arguing that the hospital and the doctor would not suffer any unfair disadvantage if the case proceeded. The application was filed without first requiring the hospital and the doctor to respond, and neither of the two opposed the request.

Justice Stella Mutuku ruled that the court had powers to make orders necessary to ensure fairness and prevent injustice. She considered the reasons presented by Ms. Mwende and the circumstances surrounding the delay. The judge allowed the application, paving the way for Ms. Mwende to formally file and pursue the medical negligence case.

However, the court attached a condition to the permission, directing that the plaint, which is the document setting out her claim against the hospital and the doctor, would be treated as properly filed only after payment of the required court fees. Ms. Mwende was given 45 days from the date of the ruling to pay the fees. The judge further directed that the costs of the application would be determined together with the outcome of the main case.

The family is seeking compensation for the death of their kin due to alleged medical negligence. The case will now proceed, and the court will determine whether the hospital and the doctor were negligent in the death of Ms. Mwikali. The outcome of the case will provide answers and accountability for the family.

The court's decision to allow the application was based on the exceptional circumstances of the case. The judge considered the reasons presented by Ms. Mwende and the circumstances surrounding the delay. The court's ruling demonstrates its commitment to ensuring fairness and preventing injustice.

Key points

  • The High Court has allowed a mother to pursue a medical negligence claim against a hospital and a doctor over the death of her daughter, which occurred over four years ago.
  • The court ruled that the mother can file a case against the hospital and the doctor outside the three-year period normally allowed for claims involving personal injuries and death caused by negligence.
  • The case will now proceed, and the court will determine whether the hospital and the doctor were negligent in the death of the daughter.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.