The Rwandan Parliament is debating the Health (Amendment) Bill, 2024, which aims to outlaw the detention of patients and bodies by health facilities over unpaid medical bills. The bill, sponsored by Kirinyaga Woman Representative Njeri Maina, proposes a fine of Sh2 million for hospital managers who detain patients or bodies. The bill states that a person in charge of a health facility shall not detain a patient who has been discharged or the body of a deceased person on grounds of non-payment of hospital bills or medical expenses.

The debate has raised concerns among lawmakers that the bill may disadvantage hospitals. Kilifi North MP Owen Baya pointed out that a section of the bill that requires patients to pay their medical bills in full before being discharged from a private or semi-private room may negate the main objective of the bill. National Assembly Health Committee Chairperson James Nyikal expressed concern that people may take advantage of the new law by choosing to be admitted to private rooms and then refusing to pay.

Some lawmakers argue that the law should serve both the hospital and the patient. Kangundo MP Fabian Kyule warned that the House cannot make rules that focus on the patient and not hospitals. He said that hospitals have incurred costs in treating patients and that the law should take care of both sides. Nyatike MP Tom Odege, a trained health practitioner, also emphasized the need for fairness to both patients and hospitals.

Other lawmakers have suggested that patients who choose to be admitted to private rooms should pay their medical bills in full before being discharged. Tigania West MP John Mutunga said that the laws made must encourage private hospitals and that patients who deliberately choose to seek treatment in private facilities should pay. Magarini MP Harrison Kombe suggested that if a hospital has to detain a patient or body, then there should be extra charges.

The bill also introduces a promissory note, a legal tool that seeks to help hospitals recover their treatment costs. The promissory note will be a legally binding document that relatives of the patient or deceased will have to sign with the respective health facility on how they are going to settle the bill. The note will indicate the duration and modalities on how the discharged patient or relatives of the deceased will clear the outstanding medical bills.

Lawmakers have raised questions on how to treat patients who need isolation in private rooms and whether they should pay or be discharged and pay later. There are also concerns that private hospitals may change all their general wards into private ones so that patients can pay. The issues, lawmakers said, will be made clearer in the regulations once the bill is assented to by the President.

The proposed law aims to balance the needs of patients and hospitals. While patients will be protected from detention over unpaid medical bills, hospitals will have the power to enforce the implementation of the promissory note in a court of law. The fine of Sh2 million for detaining patients or bodies is intended to encourage hospitals to comply with the new law.

Key points

  • Hospitals risk Sh2 million fine for detaining patients and bodies over unpaid medical bills.
  • The proposed law aims to balance the needs of patients and hospitals.
  • The bill introduces a promissory note to help hospitals recover treatment costs.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.