The Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation (NNPC) is embroiled in a controversy over unexplained entries in its financial statements, totaling ₦210 trillion. The company's former Group Chief Executive, Mele Kyari, has insisted that no such amount was lost under his watch, attributing the discrepancy to bookkeeping issues. However, this explanation has not alleviated concerns, as the issue revolves around the company's inability to account for its own audited accounts.

A Senate Public Accounts Committee review of NNPC's audited financial statements from 2017 to 2023 identified ₦103 trillion in accrued expenses and ₦107 trillion in sundry receivables. The committee rejected NNPC's explanation that the accrued expenses were linked to joint venture cash calls, as this regime had been abolished since January 2017. Furthermore, the receivables were attributed to defunct banks and other entities, but no debtors or amounts were specified.

The accounting terms used by NNPC have contributed to the public debate confusion. Accrued expenses represent liabilities or costs incurred but not yet paid, while receivables are assets or amounts owed to the company. Although the former officials are technically correct that ₦210 trillion has not disappeared, this narrow perspective misses the point. The real test in accounting is whether a balance is supported by evidence, and unexplained liabilities and assets raise red flags.

The scale of the issue is substantial, with NNPC's former Chief Financial Officer stating that the company's total revenue between 2017 and 2023 was approximately ₦54.5 trillion. This figure raises questions about how the company accrued unpaid expenses of ₦103 trillion and claimed receivables of ₦107 trillion from unnamed debtors. The explanations provided so far do not inspire confidence, and concerns about the quality of the accounts and the role of external auditors have been raised.

The International Financial Reporting Standards require receivables to be assessed for recoverability, and auditors are expected to obtain sufficient evidence for material balances. The committee has demanded that NNPC's auditors provide a complete schedule of every component of the receivables and payables, and rejected their claims of confidentiality. Nigerians are entitled to know what evidence supported these balances and what opinion was given by the auditors.

Governance concerns have been raised, as the dispute has dragged on for months, with written explanations rejected, summonses ignored, and a warrant of arrest issued against Mr. Kyari. A public company that cannot produce a schedule of its own receivables after months of parliamentary scrutiny has a governance problem. The committee has also raised queries about ₦5 trillion charged as direct production costs and an alleged ₦3.8 trillion duplication of subsidy deductions.

To address the controversy, four steps are necessary. Firstly, NNPC should publish a full reconciliation of both balances, itemized by counterparty, date, and nature, with supporting evidence. Secondly, an independent forensic audit should verify this reconciliation. Thirdly, the company should provide a documented answer to the queries raised by the committee. Finally, NNPC should prioritize transparency and accountability, as credible accounts are essential for access to capital and maintaining public trust.

Key points

  • NNPC's unexplained ₦210 trillion entries in its financial statements have raised concerns over transparency and governance.
  • The company's inability to account for its own audited accounts has sparked a controversy that requires immediate attention.
  • An independent forensic audit and transparent disclosure are necessary to resolve the issue and restore public trust.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.