A police operation in Rose-Hill, Mauritius, on October 27, 2022, has sparked a contentious civil lawsuit four years after the event. The case involves Ashik Jagai, a former member of the Special Striking Team (SST), Sanjeev Teeluckdharry, a lawyer, and two members of the Gaya family, Hemlata Sher-Gill Gaya and her son Vighnesh. The dispute centers on the circumstances of the police operation and subsequent accusations that allegedly caused significant harm to the parties involved.

The Gaya family claims that the police operation, which was conducted by members of the SST, resulted in moral prejudice. They sent a formal notice in November 2022 and filed a lawsuit in January 2023, seeking Rs 50 million in damages. In response, Ashik Jagai filed a counter-lawsuit against Sanjeev Teeluckdharry, Hemlata Sher-Gill Gaya, and Vighnesh Gaya, also seeking Rs 50 million. Jagai alleges that accusations made against him damaged his reputation.

The two lawsuits, with distinct arguments, have been ongoing since 2023. The parties have exchanged questions and clarifications to establish their positions and disputed facts. A hearing was scheduled for November 18, 2026, before the Master and Registrar of the Supreme Court. However, the outcome of the hearing and any new dates have not been officially confirmed.

The dispute raises two key questions: under what conditions can a police operation lead to civil liability, and what statements can be considered as causing compensable harm to one's reputation? The Court will need to evaluate the evidence, determine potential responsibilities, and rule on the claims for damages.

The Rs 100 million claimed corresponds to the total amount sought by both parties, not a judgment pronounced by the court. The cases have been ongoing for four years, with the parties engaged in a lengthy and complex process. The Supreme Court's decision is expected to provide clarity on the responsibilities of law enforcement and the consequences of making accusations that may harm someone's reputation.

The police operation in question was conducted by members of the SST, a specialized unit. The circumstances of the operation and the accusations made against Ashik Jagai have been disputed. The Gaya family's claims of moral prejudice and Jagai's allegations of reputational damage will be examined by the Court.

The court's ruling will have significant implications for civil liability in cases involving police operations and accusations that may harm one's reputation. The decision will provide guidance on the responsibilities of law enforcement and the consequences of making accusations that may cause harm.

Key points

  • The dispute involves a Rs 100 million lawsuit between Ashik Jagai, Sanjeev Teeluckdharry, and the Gaya family.
  • The case centers on a 2022 police operation in Rose-Hill, Mauritius, and subsequent accusations that allegedly caused harm.
  • The Supreme Court's decision will provide clarity on civil liability in cases involving police operations and accusations that may harm one's reputation.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.