The Mauritian government is facing criticism for its handling of a report on water losses in the country. In November, six experts from Singapore Corporation Enterprise (SCE) visited Mauritius to assess the situation with water losses. They submitted an interim report in just five days, which was received by Minister of Public Services Patrick Assirvaden on November 10. However, the report has yet to be submitted to parliament, raising concerns about its contents and the minister's delay in sharing it.
According to Assirvaden, the SCE experts were tasked with evaluating the current situation with water losses, identifying areas with high losses, and formulating a strategy to reduce these losses. The experts' mandate also included developing a sustainable framework for the Central Water Authority (CWA) to prioritize reducing water losses. The cost of hiring these experts was Rs 9.5 million, a significant amount that has raised eyebrows given the short timeframe in which they worked.
An investigation by Scoop.mu has revealed that the SCE experts conducted informal interviews with CWA engineers, asking them questions about their approach to addressing water shortages and leaks. Based on these interviews, the experts compiled their report, which has been criticized for lacking depth and rigor. The experts also visited some CWA stations, spending a significant amount of time in the eastern region, where the rate of non-revenue water is highest.
The methodology used by the SCE experts has been questioned by some engineers, who wonder if they were selective in their findings to justify a large-scale pipe replacement program. The experts' report has also raised concerns about the need for such a program and whether the CWA's existing Leak Detection Unit is being utilized effectively. The unit was established to detect leaks and reduce water losses, but its functionality and effectiveness are now being questioned.
The CWA had ordered sophisticated equipment in 2021 to detect leaks, but it is unclear if this equipment is being used. The use of external consultants has also raised questions about the capabilities of the CWA's own staff. Engineers are wondering if the government trusts the CWA's employees to carry out this work or if there are other motivations at play.
The delay in submitting the report to parliament has sparked concerns about transparency and accountability. Minister Assirvaden has promised to submit the report soon, but the timing and contents of the report remain uncertain. The opposition has called for greater transparency and scrutiny of the report, given the significant amount of public funds spent on hiring the SCE experts.
The controversy surrounding the SCE experts' report has highlighted the need for greater accountability and transparency in government contracting and decision-making. The Mauritian government must provide clear explanations for its actions and ensure that public funds are being used effectively to address the country's water challenges. The report's contents and the government's response to it will be closely watched by the public and opposition parties.
Key points
- The Mauritian government faces criticism for its handling of a report on water losses.
- The report was compiled by Singaporean experts in just five days.
- The experts' methodology and the government's delay in submitting the report have raised concerns about transparency and accountability.