ActionSA leader Herman Mashaba has countered allegations by DA mayoral candidate Helen Zille that EFF leader Julius Malema controlled Johannesburg's administration during his tenure as mayor. In a sworn affidavit, Mashaba claims Zille recommended that he approach former prosecutor Glynnis Breytenbach for advice on a suitable candidate to head the City of Johannesburg's Group Forensic and Investigation Service. This led to the appointment of former top cop Shadrack Sibiya, whom Zille now alleges was installed on Malema's instructions.

Mashaba's version is corroborated by Michael Beaumont, ActionSA's national chairperson, who was Mashaba's chief of staff at the time. Beaumont says he personally approached Zille for advice on potential candidates after the position became vacant. Zille directed him to Breytenbach, who subsequently recommended Sibiya due to his experience in law enforcement. Sibiya went through the city's recruitment process and was ultimately appointed. This account challenges Zille's claim that Malema instructed Mashaba to appoint Sibiya.

The dispute revolves around allegations made by Zille in an interview, where she claimed Malema dictated major municipal decisions, captured City Power, and influenced the awarding of fleet tenders for the benefit of companies linked to the EFF leader. Zille also claimed Malema instructed Mashaba to appoint Sibiya to head the city's anti-corruption unit. Mashaba has rejected these allegations, saying he had no prior relationship with Sibiya and that Malema played no role in bringing him to his attention.

Mashaba's affidavit provides further detail on how the recruitment process unfolded. He says he did not know Sibiya before the recommendation and had no prior relationship with him. Mashaba also disputes Zille's claims that Malema dictated municipal fleet tenders or facilitated the capture of City Power through his office. He denies discussing municipal tenders with Malema and did not receive instructions from him concerning procurement decisions.

The dispute also revisits the Public Protector's investigation into Sibiya's appointment. Malema argues that Public Protector Report No 24 of 2020/21 made no adverse findings against him or the EFF in relation to the appointment. Malema claims the allegations are particularly damaging, suggesting he used political influence to secure private commercial benefits from municipal resources. He instructed his attorneys to send Zille a letter of demand, asking her to retract the statements and apologise.

Malema says Zille's allegations portray him as a political leader who exploited public institutions for private gain. He argues that Zille's reference to companies operating as his fronts implies that he concealed his financial interests behind corporate entities to benefit from procurement processes. The dispute comes amid renewed coalition negotiations following the November 4 local government elections.

Mashaba says Zille's allegations appear to be politically motivated and intended to undermine ActionSA's position in Johannesburg's coalition negotiations. The counter-claims by Mashaba and Malema directly challenge Zille's allegations, adding another layer to the complex dispute between the three leaders.

Key points

  • Mashaba claims Zille recommended Sibiya's appointment
  • Zille alleges Malema controlled Johannesburg's administration
  • Public Protector's report found no adverse findings against Malema or EFF

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.