The Supreme Court of Appeal in Malawi has rejected a bid by three former senior executives of Press Corporation Limited (PCL) plc for K10.5 billion in advance payment. This amount represents 75 percent of the K14.1 billion compensation awarded to them by the Industrial Relations Court (IRC) in 2024 for unfair dismissal. The executives are George Partridge, Bernard Ndau, and Elizabeth Mafeni.

The Supreme Court's judgement, delivered in Blantyre, upheld Deputy Chief Justice Lovemore Chikopa's verdict from May this year. Chikopa had ruled that the payment should be suspended pending an appeal at the High Court. An 11-member Supreme Court panel, led by Chief Justice Rizine Mzikamanda, made the ruling without hearing oral submissions from any of the parties.

The court stated that a party seeking the intervention of the full court must demonstrate a proper basis for reviewing a single justice's decision. However, the three former executives failed to do so. The Supreme Court's decision was delivered after a lengthy review process, with Mzikamanda acknowledging the delay and thanking the parties for their patience.

The case has a complex history, dating back to October 2024 when PCL plc applied to the IRC to suspend the payment pending appeal at the High Court. Initially, the IRC ordered the company to pay 70 percent of the awarded amount, approximately K9.88 billion. The company escalated the matter to the High Court, which allowed the suspension of payment but ordered PCL plc to pay 75 percent of the total amount.

In response, PCL plc approached the Supreme Court, and Chikopa ruled on May 12 that the company should deposit K200 million to the High Court as security instead. Partridge, Ndau, and Mafeni sought a review by the Supreme Court's full bench, which has now been dismissed. The initial IRC ruling awarded Mafeni K8.25 billion, Partridge K3.27 billion, and Ndau K2.68 billion.

The payments were initially ordered to be made within 10 days from April 25, 2025. The trio was dismissed in 2021 following a functional review initiated by the PCL board and conducted by a consultant. Partridge is now the Governor of the Reserve Bank of Malawi. The Supreme Court's decision was unanimous, with the full bench dismissing the application.

The Supreme Court's decision brings an end to the latest development in the long-standing dispute between the former executives and PCL plc. The company had argued that the payment should be suspended pending the appeal, and the Supreme Court's ruling has upheld this position. The case highlights the complexities of Malawi's judicial system and the challenges of resolving disputes involving large sums of money.

Key points

  • The Supreme Court of Malawi has rejected a K10.5 billion bid by ex-PCL executives pending the hearing of their compensation appeal.
  • The executives were awarded K14.1 billion by the Industrial Relations Court in 2024 for unfair dismissal.
  • The Supreme Court's decision was unanimous, with the full bench dismissing the application.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.