The murder trial of former ANC Youth League secretary-general Sindiso Magaqa has faced a potential delay after the defence sought the recusal of two senior prosecutors from the case. The application was raised in the Pietermaritzburg High Court on Monday by advocate Simphiwe Mlotshwa, representing accused number three, former uMzimkhulu municipal manager Zweliphansi Stanley Skhosana. Mlotshwa told Judge Mluleki Chithi that he intended to apply for the recusal of deputy director of public prosecutions, advocate Lawrence Gcaba, and senior state advocate Elvis Gcweka.

The state indicated that it would oppose the application, with Gcaba raising concerns about both the timing of the move and its possible implications for the proceedings. The issue emerged shortly before the state was expected to begin presenting its evidence, with Gcaba informing the court that the prosecution had not received amended Section 220 admissions from the defence. Mlotshwa then informed the court of his intention to bring the recusal application, explaining that he had only completed drafting the papers over the weekend.

Judge Chithi questioned why the court had not been alerted earlier, pointing out that the matter had been scheduled to proceed and that arrangements had already been made for the trial. Gcaba said the state was concerned that the application had not been raised during previous pre-trial conferences, including the most recent meeting on November 5. He further argued that the application could have wider implications for the proceedings.

The state subsequently indicated that it would formally oppose the application through written submissions. Advocate Mduduzi Mvune, who represented co-accused Mbulelo Mpofana and Sbonelo Myeza, told the court that his clients were not involved in the application. Following an adjournment, the legal representatives were asked to prepare a draft order setting out the deadlines for the exchange of court papers and the hearing of the application.

Magaqa was shot in July 2017, a few kilometres from his home in Ibisi, uMzimkhulu, and later died in hospital. Skhosana, Mpofana and Myeza have pleaded not guilty to charges including murder, conspiracy to commit murder, attempted murder and unlawful possession of firearms and ammunition. A fourth accused, Sibusiso Ncengwa, previously pleaded guilty to his involvement in the killing and is serving a 25-year prison sentence.

The case was remanded to November 25. The defence's recusal bid has added to the delays in the trial, which has been ongoing for several years. The prosecution has expressed concerns about the impact of the application on the proceedings, and the court will have to consider the matter before deciding on the next course of action.

The murder trial is one of several high-profile cases in South Africa that have faced delays due to various factors, including recusal bids and lack of evidence. The case has garnered significant attention due to the prominence of the accused and the severity of the charges. The court is expected to make a decision on the recusal bid in the coming weeks, which will determine the next steps in the trial.

Key points

  • The defence's recusal bid has caused a delay in the murder trial of former ANC Youth League secretary-general Sindiso Magaqa.
  • The state has indicated that it will oppose the application, citing concerns about the timing and implications for the proceedings.
  • The case has been remanded to November 25, with the court to consider the recusal bid before deciding on the next course of action.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.