The Ministry of Justice in Liberia has defied a court order to release the IB Atlantic IV vessel and its seven crew members by the stipulated deadline of 4:00 p.m. on Wednesday, November 18. The court order was issued by Assigned Circuit Judge D. Onesimus Banwon of Criminal Court ‘A’ for Montserrado County following a habeas corpus petition challenging the continued detention of the vessel and its crew. As of 5:00 p.m. on Wednesday, the vessel and its crew remained under state custody.
The seven crew members were still detained aboard the vessel, and their lawyers confirmed that they had not been released. Judge Banwon had left the court premises at approximately 4:00 p.m., around the time the deadline expired. The apparent failure to comply with the order has raised questions about the Ministry's handling of the case and the legal basis for the continued detention of the vessel and its crew.
Solicitor General Cllr. Abrahim Sillah declined to provide an explanation for the delay when contacted late Wednesday evening. He referred FrontPage Africa to the court for information. Sources within the Ministry of Justice disclosed that the Ministry was still struggling to formulate an explanation for the continued detention of the vessel and its crew.
The detention of the IB Atlantic IV and its seven crew members has become one of Liberia's most unusual maritime security cases. The vessel was first spotted off York Island in Grand Cape Mount County in August. The Comoros-flagged vessel attracted attention after lingering in Liberian coastal waters, prompting concerns among residents and security authorities.
The situation escalated when Liberian security forces attempted to intercept the vessel as it moved farther offshore toward Rivercess County. The vessel was eventually intercepted by Ivorian authorities on August 9. Liberia's Information Minister Jerolinmek M. Piah confirmed that the vessel had been arrested by Ivorian authorities and disclosed that the Liberian Government was engaging its Ivorian counterpart to facilitate its return.
The vessel was returned to Liberia in late August, reportedly arriving on August 27 under the command of the Liberian Coast Guard. Despite its return, the vessel and its crew remained under security control, with no comprehensive public account of the investigation's findings. The continued detention prompted the vessel's management and the seven crew members to seek judicial intervention through a habeas corpus petition.
The failure to release the vessel and its crew by the stipulated time has brought renewed attention to compliance with judicial orders and the constitutional protections afforded to persons held by state authorities. The case presents an increasingly difficult challenge for the government, which must explain the circumstances that led to the vessel's pursuit, its interception in Côte d’Ivoire, its return to Liberia, and the prolonged detention of its crew.
Key points
- The Ministry of Justice's failure to comply with the court order has raised concerns about the government's handling of the case and the legal basis for the continued detention of the vessel and its crew.