Four women, including Kelsea Tadiwa Tafirenyika, the 22-year-old second wife of President Emmerson Mnangagwa's twin son, Collins, were convicted on drug possession charges and fined amounts ranging from US$100 to US$300. The women, along with Kelsea's mother, sister, and aunt, were hurried through guilty pleas in two separate courts in Harare, Zimbabwe. Lawyers have questioned the procedures used in the cases, citing "festivals of irregularity" and raising concerns about the validity of the convictions.
A ZimLive analysis of the cases has uncovered a series of questionable procedural decisions involving magistrates, prosecutors, and a lawyer representing the women. The concerns centre on three major issues: the reopening of a case after it had been formally postponed, the introduction of new charges without following the prescribed arrest and charge procedures, and guilty pleas entered by a lawyer without the accused personally confirming their admission of guilt to the magistrate.
Kelsea's case in Harare provides the clearest illustration of the alleged irregularities. She was initially arrested on a charge of unlawful dealing in dangerous drugs under section 156(1)(a) of the Criminal Law (Codification and Reform) Act. During a police raid on her Greystone Park home on August 4, she had been found in possession of an assortment of drugs, including morphine, pethidine, and cannabis. Her lawyer, Malvern Mapako, had consented to a postponement to October 27, which was granted by magistrate Winfilda Tiyatara.
However, barely 24 hours later, Kelsea was back in court before a different magistrate, Ignatio Kudakwashe Mhene. The prosecutor, Mandirasa Chigumira, had requested and obtained the postponement to October 27 just the previous day. Kelsea was now represented by Advocate Silvester Hashiti, who tendered pleas of "guilty" on Kelsea's behalf to both counts, resulting in fines of US$300 on the first and US$100 on the second.
Lawyers have questioned how the new charges came to be introduced without Kelsea being formally processed again. They told ZimLive that because the prescription medicine charge arose under a separate law, police should have summoned or arrested her on the new allegation, recorded a fresh warned and cautioned statement, and then taken her through the ordinary process of appearing in court. There is no indication in the record that this happened.
The procedure used to enter the guilty pleas has also been questioned. According to section 271(2)(b) of the Criminal Procedure and Evidence Act, the magistrate must establish the facts supporting the charge by asking the prosecutor to outline the alleged acts or omissions constituting the offence. The court must then establish from the accused personally whether she understands the charge and its essential elements, and whether her plea amounts to an admission of those elements and the facts alleged.
Sources say the four women left Zimbabwe for South Africa shortly after paying their fines, with Dubai believed to have been their ultimate destination. The cases have raised concerns about the handling of drug cases involving individuals linked to the President's family and the need for greater transparency and accountability in the justice system.
Key points
- The convictions of four women linked to President Emmerson Mnangagwa's family have raised concerns about the handling of their drug cases.
- Lawyers have questioned the procedures used in the cases, citing "festivals of irregularity" and raising concerns about the validity of the convictions.
- The cases have highlighted the need for greater transparency and accountability in the justice system, particularly in cases involving individuals linked to those in power.