University of Nairobi law professor Prof Migai Akech has applied to join former Deputy President Rigathi Gachagua's impeachment appeal as an 'amicus curiae'. He argues that Parliament's process violated constitutional safeguards designed to protect the country's top two leaders. Prof Akech claims the 2010 Constitution adopts a "bad actor" model, which requires a fair process to test allegations and protect the officeholder's right to respond. He contrasts this with a "political reset" model, which allows removal from office to resolve political deadlock.

The impeachment process followed the breakdown of relations between President William Ruto and his deputy, culminating in Parliament's October 2024 proceedings. Kibwezi West MP Mwengi Mutuse introduced a motion containing 11 allegations against Mr Gachagua, including divisive remarks, undermining government policy, and amassing wealth through corruption. Mr Gachagua denied the allegations, explaining that his statements had been taken out of context and that he had not undermined the President or the government. The National Assembly invited public views and gave Mr Gachagua two hours to defend himself before MPs.

Prof Akech argues that Parliament failed to provide safeguards central to the "bad actor" model, including proper investigations, adequate preparation time, and an opportunity to challenge evidence. He disputes the public participation conducted by the National Assembly, saying citizens had less than 48 hours and were not given Mr Gachagua's response or supporting evidence. The High Court's June 8, 2026 judgment upheld the impeachment but found that the Senate violated Mr Gachagua's fair-hearing rights by refusing to adjourn when he was absent.

The High Court awarded Mr Gachagua Sh50 million in constitutional damages, but Prof Akech differs with the judges' reasoning and findings. He argues that Article 2(4) requires an unconstitutional decision to be treated as invalid and that the High Court should have examined whether the charges were properly investigated and supported. Prof Akech proposes applying the "de facto officer doctrine" to protect official acts performed by Prof Kithure Kindiki under an apparently valid appointment.

Prof Akech believes that Gachagua's impeachment risks normalising the use of parliamentary majorities to remove elected leaders over political or policy disagreements, weakening the voters' mandate and destabilising governments. He says it could also undermine the Deputy President's constitutional role as a counterweight to the President and encourage divisive politics. The Deputy President is elected on the same ticket as the President and has a direct mandate from voters.

Prof Akech wants the Court of Appeal to allow his participation in the case as a friend of the court, overturn the High Court's decision, and nullify Mr Gachagua's impeachment. He believes that the appellate court should reject the argument that reinstating Mr Gachagua would create two Deputy Presidents and apply the de facto officer doctrine to preserve official acts performed by Prof Kindiki.

The Senate is also disputing the High Court's decision, and the Court of Appeal will have to consider the competing arguments. The outcome of the appeal will have significant implications for the country's constitutional framework and the balance of power between the executive and legislative branches.

Key points

  • Prof Akech argues that Parliament's impeachment process violated due-process safeguards.
  • The High Court's decision upheld the impeachment but found that the Senate violated Mr Gachagua's fair-hearing rights.
  • Prof Akech proposes applying the "de facto officer doctrine" to protect official acts performed by Prof Kithure Kindiki.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.