Judicial Tribunal Hears Evidence in Judge Misconduct Case

The Judicial Conduct Tribunal hearing into complaints against Eastern Cape Judge Belinda Hartle has heard emotional testimonies and alarming revelations. Director of Court Operations in the Eastern Cape, Denim Kroqwana, took the stand and provided an account of his encounter with Thozamile Semekazi, an official of the Eastern Cape High Court, who was reportedly "sobbing" during their meeting following the alleged incident. Kroqwana expressed concern for Semekazi's well-being and working relationship with Judge Hartle.

Kroqwana's testimony revealed that he had a meeting with Judge Hartle, which was not part of his initial statement to the tribunal. Judge Boissie Mbha, presiding over the tribunal, questioned Kroqwana about the meeting, and he explained that the interaction was informal and happened in a passage. Kroqwana stated that he omitted the incident from his statement due to its informal nature. The tribunal is investigating Semekazi's claims that Judge Hartle verbally assaulted him using offensive language.

Semekazi alleges that Judge Hartle used the k-word during a confrontation in May 2025, while Judge Hartle acknowledges using a swear word but denies using the k-word. The tribunal has also heard that Semekazi had initiated contact with Judge Hartle's husband, journalist Ray Hartle, in 2024, raising questions about his motives. Semekazi had previously denied any communication with Ray before the publication of an article alleging that he had solicited bribes.

Evidence leader advocate Benny Kalakgosi disclosed that Semekazi had recently admitted to lying about three phone calls, confirming that he had reached out to Ray Hartle himself on one occasion in March 2024. This development has sparked speculation about the motives behind Semekazi's allegations. The tribunal proceedings were delayed due to safety concerns after "death threats" directed at Semekazi were posted on the livestream of the proceedings.

Despite the alleged threats, Semekazi told the tribunal that he wanted to get the cross-examination over and done with. The tribunal, which continues to hear evidence from various witnesses, is expected to conclude on Wednesday, November 18. Judge Mbha is investigating the allegations against Judge Hartle, who has vehemently denied using the k-word.

The case has taken a complex turn with multiple revelations and allegations. Semekazi's credibility has been questioned after he admitted to lying about phone calls. The tribunal will consider all the evidence presented before making a determination.

The Judicial Conduct Tribunal's findings will have significant implications for Judge Hartle's career and the broader judicial system. The tribunal's conclusion is eagerly anticipated as it will bring clarity to the allegations and determine the next course of action.

Key points

• Judge Belinda Hartle faces allegations of verbal assault and misconduct.
• The Judicial Conduct Tribunal hearing has heard emotional testimonies and revelations.
• Semekazi's credibility has been questioned after admitting to lying about phone calls.