The High Court in Juba has discharged three of the four people accused in connection with the death of 24-year-old Atoch Chol Lang. The court's decision was made on Monday, with presiding Judge Peter Mazin dismissing the charges against Sweety Oliver Wani, Sandra John, and Hussein Al-Hassan Ismail due to insufficient evidence. The three were ordered to be released unless they were being held in connection with other cases.
The court's ruling was based on the consideration of evidence presented by the prosecution, including testimony from the investigating officer and other witnesses, a reconstruction of the crime scene, and video footage shown to the court. Judge Mazin stated that the evidence against the three discharged accused did not meet the required legal threshold to warrant charges. In contrast, the court found sufficient evidence to proceed with charges against the fourth accused, Ronnie Robert Laku.
Atoch Chol Lang's body was discovered in a swimming pool at the Imperial Plaza Hotel in Juba on September 26 last year. She was the daughter of the First Vice-President of the Council of States. Following the discovery, police arranged for a post-mortem examination to establish the cause of death. The examination revealed that Atoch died from a sharp blow to the back of the neck, which caused bleeding.
During the proceedings, the prosecution presented statements recorded from the four accused, a witness statement concerning the arrival of the body at Juba Hospital, and an autopsy report. The court also viewed video footage said to show the movements of the deceased and the accused persons. Three of the accused challenged aspects of their recorded statements, raising concerns over missing information, inconsistencies, and inaccuracies.
The four were charged under Articles 140, 113, and 206 of the South Sudan Penal Code of 2008 in connection with Atoch's death. The court has scheduled November 20, 2026, for the next hearing as proceedings continue against Ronnie Robert Laku. The case has garnered significant attention due to Atoch's position as the daughter of a high-ranking government official.
Judge Mazin emphasized that the decision to discharge three of the accused was based on a thorough evaluation of the evidence presented. He stated that the court had carefully considered the testimony of the investigating officer, prosecution witnesses, and the video recording, as well as examined the accused persons. The judge's ruling highlights the importance of sufficient evidence in warranting charges against accused individuals.
The case is ongoing, with the next hearing scheduled for November 20, 2026. The prosecution will continue to present its case against Ronnie Robert Laku, who faces a murder charge. The court's decision to discharge three of the accused has raised questions about the investigation and the evidence collected. The outcome of the case will be closely watched, particularly given Atoch's connection to a high-ranking government official.
Key points
- The Juba High Court discharged three of four accused in Atoch Chol Lang's death due to insufficient evidence.
- One accused, Ronnie Robert Laku, faces a murder charge and will continue to face proceedings.
- The case has garnered significant attention due to Atoch's position as the daughter of the First Vice-President of the Council of States.