The defence in the corruption trial of former crime intelligence head Richard Mdluli and his two co-accused, Heine Barnard and Solomon Lazarus, has challenged the legality of a search conducted at Mdluli's Brackenfell, Cape Town, home. Mdluli's attorney, Frans Mashele, argued that the search warrant was handled unlawfully and that the investigating officer, retired Col Kobus Roelofse, exceeded the authority granted by the magistrate. The search warrant was issued for documents and exhibits relating to the Vosloorus murder case and classified crime intelligence documents.
The defence scrutinised the items seized during the operation, comparing them with those listed in the search warrant. Mashele argued that nothing relating to the Vosloorus case was found during the search, yet items not listed in the warrant were seized. Roelofse conceded that some of the items seized were not listed in the warrant but maintained that he had acted within his duties. The warrant authorised the seizure of specific documents, but Mashele questioned the timing of the search, which started at 5.20pm and ended at 8.45pm, despite the warrant stating it had to be executed during the course of the day.
Roelofse explained that the team received the warrant after 2pm and had to meet before proceeding to the property. He said once they started executing a warrant, they had to complete the search. Mashele questioned why the team had not waited until the next morning to conduct the search within the prescribed hours. Roelofse maintained that he had executed the warrant in good faith. The validity of the warrant also came under scrutiny after Roelofse admitted that he had not noticed that the affidavit used to obtain it was undated.
Mdluli, Barnard, and Lazarus face 19 charges, including corruption, fraud, theft, contraventions of the Prevention of Organised Crime Act (Poca), and defeating the ends of justice. The charges relate to the alleged misuse of the crime intelligence slush fund between 2008 and 2012, from which Mdluli and his family are alleged to have benefited. The Pretoria high court is currently hearing a trial-within-a-trial which centres on the legality of three search warrants and whether documents obtained from properties in Brackenfell and Brooklyn should be admitted as evidence in the main trial.
The defence is challenging the admissibility of evidence obtained through the search warrants. Mashele accused Roelofse of misleading the magistrate who authorised the warrant by using the Vosloorus murder case to obtain the warrant, while intending to search for material relating to other crime intelligence matters. He argued that the magistrate would not have granted the warrant had she known that Mdluli was already in custody and that the search would extend to another investigation.
Mashele said he would argue for the warrant to be declared inadmissible because it was based on an undated affidavit, executed outside the permitted hours, and used to seize items not authorised by the warrant. The matter has been rolled over to Tuesday. Roelofse had previously testified about how he investigated and arrested Mdluli in connection with the 1999 probe into the murder of Oupa Ramogibe in Vosloorus.
The trial-within-a-trial will continue to determine the validity of the search warrants and the admissibility of evidence obtained. The defence's challenge to the search warrant is a crucial part of the trial, as it could potentially impact the prosecution's case against Mdluli and his co-accused. The court's decision on the matter will be closely watched.
Key points
- The defence has challenged the legality of a search warrant issued in Richard Mdluli's corruption trial.
- The investigating officer, retired Col Kobus Roelofse, has been accused of misleading the magistrate who authorised the warrant.
- The trial-within-a-trial will continue to determine the validity of the search warrants and the admissibility of evidence obtained.