In a recent ruling, Justice Ebrima Jaiteh of the Gambia High Court granted plaintiff Abubacarr Jawara permission to present rebuttal evidence in the form of audio recordings. The recordings are said to contradict statements made by defendant Saihou Drammeh during cross-examination. This decision was made after Jawara's counsel, I. Drameh, made an oral application under Order XXXV, Rule 8.
The case involves a dispute where Drammeh had denied several allegations put to him during cross-examination. Counsel Drameh argued that the audio recordings would demonstrate that these denials were untrue on material issues. The proposed rebuttal evidence is expected to be served on both defendants, Kaddijah Kebbeh and Drammeh, in advance. Counsel for Kebbeh did not object to the application, while counsel for Drammeh, Badou S. M. Conteh, opposed it.
Justice Jaiteh framed four key issues for determination: the validity of the leave sought under Rules 8 and 9, the admissibility of the recordings as rebuttal evidence, potential prejudice, and whether justice favours granting leave with safeguards. The judge cited Rogers v Manley (1880) and a Jamaican decision in Lilieth Douglas v Errol Francis, establishing that rebuttal evidence may be admitted to explain, contradict or answer material defence evidence.
The ruling allows Jawara to tender the audio recordings as rebuttal evidence, subject to certain conditions. The recordings must be served on both defendants and filed with the Registrar, along with a schedule identifying the portions relied upon and the testimony they are intended to rebut. Jawara must also establish the relevance, authenticity, and admissibility of the recordings under the Evidence Act, 1994, and section 188 of the Information and Communications Act, 2009.
To ensure fairness, the court ordered that the defendants be given advance disclosure of the recordings and the opportunity to challenge their admissibility. The defendants may object to admissibility or relevance and, if admitted, may cross-examine and seek recall or responsive evidence. Non-English recordings require a verified English transcription.
The matter has been adjourned for the tendering of the rebuttal evidence. The court's decision emphasizes that closure of the defence case alone does not bar material rebuttal evidence. Justice Jaiteh stressed that the ruling does not establish that Drammeh gave false evidence or that the recordings contradict his testimony.
The case will continue with the presentation of the rebuttal evidence, and the court will determine its admissibility and relevance. The decision highlights the court's commitment to ensuring fairness and allowing parties to present relevant evidence. The next hearing will focus on laying a foundation for the recordings through a competent witness and establishing their admissibility.
Key points
- The Gambia High Court has granted Abubacarr Jawara leave to present audio recordings as rebuttal evidence against defendant Saihou Drammeh's testimony.
- The court's decision is subject to certain conditions, including advance disclosure and the opportunity for defendants to challenge admissibility.
- The case has been adjourned for the tendering of the rebuttal evidence, and the court will determine its admissibility and relevance.